• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Europeans chanting Rudram -comments

  • Thread starter Thread starter Somayaji.S
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.


Sanathana Dharma is for the whole universe.
So any living entity right from the North Pole till the South Pole and anywhere else in between in entitled to chant it.

I know many Indians feel surprised or even ashamed of themselves when they see other races chanting Vedas better than them but this feeling comes becos we Indians feel that Vedas is solely the property of ourselves.

That Mamaiva feeling has to go..Vedas belong to no one in specific.. it belongs to everyone.

So be happy to see Europeans and Americans reciting Vedas too.

Wait for the day where the whole world recites Vedas.

Loka Samastha Sukhino Bhavantu.

There is nothing else to comment.
 
Last edited:
Kauai Aadheenam was founded by Saivaguru Sivaya Subramuniyaswami.

In 1986, the World Religious Parliament in New Delhi honored him as one of five modern-day Jagadacharyas, or international religious teachers, that had most dynamically promoted Hinduism in the past 25 years. He became a spokesman for Hinduism at global gatherings, despite (directly) representing fewer than three million of the world's estimated one billion Hindus. His influence reflected the reach of his publications, including the approximately 30 books he wrote. He represented Hinduism at the Global Forum of Spiritual and Parliamentary Leaders in Oxford in 1988, Moscow in 1990 and Rio de Janeiro in 1992. The book Religious Leaders of America explained Subramuniyaswami's role as "a pillar of orthodox Hinduism"

Sivaya Subramuniyaswami - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

He is the only Guru who wrote How to become a Hindu.

Himalayan Academy Publications - How to Become a Hindu

He is a Saiva Siddhanta follower.

Being pure Saivas his followers have a better right to chant the Rudram than most of the Smarthas who are not Saivas.
 
Better still, if they all convert to or adopt hindu way of life. There is a belief that the whole world followed sanatana dharma; strayed souls are welcome. Then they get the right to chant and study.

Only doctors are allowed to prescribe, only qualified surgeons are allowed to cut, only certified pharmacists are allowed to sell medicines. Many without qualification and certificates do all these, but it is not right. In pudukkotai one eleven year old boy did caesarian after watching his doctor father do it. The doctor father claimed that he took the patient's permission!


Sanathana Dharma is for the whole universe.
So any living entity right from the North Pole till the South Pole and anywhere else in between in entitled to chant it.

I know many Indians feel surprised or even ashamed of themselves when they see other races chanting Vedas better than them but this feeling comes becos we Indians feel that Vedas is solely the property of ourselves.

That Mamaiva feeling has to go..Vedas belong to no one in specific.. it belongs to everyone.

So be happy to see Europeans and Americans reciting Vedas too.

Wait for the day where the whole world recites Vedas.

Loka Samastha Sukhino Bhavantu.

There is nothing else to comment.
 
Better still, if they all convert to or adopt hindu way of life. There is a belief that the whole world followed sanatana dharma; strayed souls are welcome. Then they get the right to chant and study.

Only doctors are allowed to prescribe, only qualified surgeons are allowed to cut, only certified pharmacists are allowed to sell medicines. Many without qualification and certificates do all these, but it is not right. In pudukkotai one eleven year old boy did caesarian after watching his doctor father do it. The doctor father claimed that he took the patient's permission!

You are assuming that they are not Hindus. You are wrong. They are all Hindus.
 
hi
i know kuai monastry personally...i met the swamiji twice.....they follow saiva siddhanta of jaffna sri lanka...some of the

swamijis know tamil and their IRAIVAN TEMPLE was constructed by our famous Ganapathi stapathi....read HINDUISM TODAY...

the quarterly magazine published by himalayan academy abt global hinduism...
 

Shri Somayaji sir,

For the brahmins of India (Bharat) chanting rudra and vedas had been the full time avocation for centuries, if not millennia. They have lost everything and have gained hardly any benefit as a result thereof and so the recent generations have been forsaking that prescribed way of life and taking up every other sort of occupation/job which will feed them and give them a satisfactory life in the present world.

The Europeans have been following either the brand of Christianity available locally or were compelled by Russian communism to throw religion out of their lives. Satya Sai groups have managed to collect people, bring them on "tourism" basis to the Sai Baba Ashram at Puttaparthi and these sai devotees have, naturally, felt that a fascinating new experience is opened to them by adhering to the Indian ways of devotion.

It needs no mention that a person who gets impressed by another human being (be it Satya Sai, Chandrasekharendra Saraswati, or any other mortal human) and is ready to believe that the latter (the "impressor") is verily GOD, is highly gullible. Therefore, these European Sai devotees might be chanting rudram in the belief that it will bring them fulfilment of all or most of their worldly desires.

After a few centuries, if not much earlier, they/their descendants will also throw away these things and go in search of money. The learned poet Magha did not say empty words when he told,

न भुज्यते व्याकरणं क्षुधातुरैः
पिपासितैः काव्यरसो न पीयते
न विद्यया केनचिदुद्धृतं कुलं
हिरण्यमॆवार्ज्जय निष्फला कला

(na bhujyate vyākaraṇaṃ kṣudhāturaiḥ
pipāsitaiḥ kāvyaraso na pīyate
na vidyayā kenaciduddhṛtaṃ kulaṃ
hiraṇyamevārjjaya niṣphalā kalā)

(A hungry fellow does not eat grammar, a thirsty person does not drink poetry; one's family does not get high status by mere vidyA or knowledge, so earn money - art is useless.)

I think what applies to art can also apply to religious scriptures.
 
No fear, no worry. Sanatana dharma emphasises cyclic nature of everything, the period or time constant may vary for different things, from a few kshanas to yugas.

All the old mutts and modern asrams run vedic schools. I know a few cases of sons of well to do corporate executives voluntarily choosing veda patasalas. If left to follow natural instincts, some will chase money, some women and some spiritual pursuits. As long as the crusaders don't take up the sword to physically eliminate the devout, veda learning tribe will survive. Some tried in the middle ages by sword and now by some by money and brain washing route.

Jagadguru Sri Ramabhadracharya, born blind, runs a university for handicapped in Chitrakoot and is involved in "free Vedic scriptures and Stotras for the Blind people".

Vedic scriptures and stotras for the Blind people in Braille
Rambhadracharya - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Shri Somayaji sir,

For the brahmins of India (Bharat) chanting rudra and vedas had been the full time avocation for centuries, if not millennia. They have lost everything and have gained hardly any benefit as a result thereof and so the recent generations have been forsaking that prescribed way of life and taking up every other sort of occupation/job which will feed them and give them a satisfactory life in the present world.

The Europeans have been following either the brand of Christianity available locally or were compelled by Russian communism to throw religion out of their lives. Satya Sai groups have managed to collect people, bring them on "tourism" basis to the Sai Baba Ashram at Puttaparthi and these sai devotees have, naturally, felt that a fascinating new experience is opened to them by adhering to the Indian ways of devotion.

It needs no mention that a person who gets impressed by another human being (be it Satya Sai, Chandrasekharendra Saraswati, or any other mortal human) and is ready to believe that the latter (the "impressor") is verily GOD, is highly gullible. Therefore, these European Sai devotees might be chanting rudram in the belief that it will bring them fulfilment of all or most of their worldly desires.

After a few centuries, if not much earlier, they/their descendants will also throw away these things and go in search of money. The learned poet Magha did not say empty words when he told,

न भुज्यते व्याकरणं क्षुधातुरैः
पिपासितैः काव्यरसो न पीयते
न विद्यया केनचिदुद्धृतं कुलं
हिरण्यमॆवार्ज्जय निष्फला कला

(na bhujyate vyākaraṇaṃ kṣudhāturaiḥ
pipāsitaiḥ kāvyaraso na pīyate
na vidyayā kenaciduddhṛtaṃ kulaṃ
hiraṇyamevārjjaya niṣphalā kalā)

(A hungry fellow does not eat grammar, a thirsty person does not drink poetry; one's family does not get high status by mere vidyA or knowledge, so earn money - art is useless.)

I think what applies to art can also apply to religious scriptures.
 
Therefore, these European Sai devotees might be chanting rudram in the belief that it will bring them fulfilment of all or most of their worldly desires.

After a few centuries, if not much earlier, they/their descendants will also throw away these things and go in search of money. The learned poet Magha did not say empty words when he told,

न भुज्यते व्याकरणं क्षुधातुरैः
पिपासितैः काव्यरसो न पीयते
न विद्यया केनचिदुद्धृतं कुलं
हिरण्यमॆवार्ज्जय निष्फला कला

(na bhujyate vyākaraṇaṃ kṣudhāturaiḥ
pipāsitaiḥ kāvyaraso na pīyate
na vidyayā kenaciduddhṛtaṃ kulaṃ
hiraṇyamevārjjaya niṣphalā kalā)

(A hungry fellow does not eat grammar, a thirsty person does not drink poetry; one's family does not get high status by mere vidyA or knowledge, so earn money - art is useless.)

I think what applies to art can also apply to religious scriptures.


Dear Sangom Ji,

I have personally met many European/American devotees who are truly not praying for worldly desires.
Some were super rich and gave up everything for a peaceful quiet life in the Ashram.

They personally view God as a universal friend and are happy to pray just for praying sake.

In fact it is many of us Indians who are becoming less "Dharmic" and more "worldly" that there is a joke that goes around that when they next Avatar comes He will weed out the miscreants and uplift Dharma and going by the looks of it we Indians might be on the Avatar's list for weeding!

BTW Magha's in his Shishupala Vada was known to have the combination of Kalidasa's appropriate similes, Bharavi's profundity of meaning and Dandin's elegance in words.

So if we could all just let anyone be the Dasa of God..illuminating the intellect with the Bha Ravi(Sun of effulgence)..in no time all of us in this world will be Dandins(carrying a staff).

So I feel never underestimate the devotion of anyone else.
 
In most of the Hare Rama Krishna temples across the globe, you will find various nationalities including Black, white, hispanic etc chanting slokas and mantras with ease
 
Last edited:
Dear Sangom Ji,

I have personally met many European/American devotees who are truly not praying for worldly desires.
Some were super rich and gave up everything for a peaceful quiet life in the Ashram.

They personally view God as a universal friend and are happy to pray just for praying sake.

In fact it is many of us Indians who are becoming less "Dharmic" and more "worldly" that there is a joke that goes around that when they next Avatar comes He will weed out the miscreants and uplift Dharma and going by the looks of it we Indians might be on the Avatar's list for weeding!

BTW Magha's in his Shishupala Vada was known to have the combination of Kalidasa's appropriate similes, Bharavi's profundity of meaning and Dandin's elegance in words.

So if we could all just let anyone be the Dasa of God..illuminating the intellect with the Bha Ravi(Sun of effulgence)..in no time all of us in this world will be Dandins(carrying a staff).

So I feel never underestimate the devotion of anyone else.

Smt. Renuka,

While I apologize for branding all the European rudra & veda chanters as people wanting fulfilment of their worldly desires, what followed were the undernoted lines:

"After a few centuries, if not much earlier, they/their descendants will also throw away these things and go in search of money. The learned poet Magha did not say empty words when he told,..."

I meant to say that nothing will remain unchanged, no phenomenon will remain eternal in this world except perhaps this Jagat itself!

Though I appreciate the imagery in your following sentences, I do not subscribe to your view that "if we could all just let anyone be the Dasa of God..illuminating the intellect with the Bha Ravi(Sun of effulgence)..in no time all of us in this world will be Dandins(carrying a staff)." I am of the considered view that the concept of a god who is external to Man for whom humans should have bhakti and should become "Dasas" (which means slaves, not only servants) is a false notion which people who, from the times of the Shamans and witch-doctors, claimed themselves to be mediators between humans and their imagined exotic, superhuman gods, used very effectively to subdue the common man's rational questioning of the practices and pronouncements of those witch-doctors, medicine-men, shamans, etc.

Religionists, which means the priesthood in each religion religiously preserved this (wrong) notion because they stood to benefit by doing so.

While nobody in the modern world will probably prevent anyone from being a Dasa of any god, that trend also will vanish in its own appropriate time, imho. Only, you and I may not be there to witness it as sangom or Renuka.
 
Shri Somayaji sir,

It needs no mention that a person who gets impressed by another human being (be it Satya Sai, Chandrasekharendra Saraswati, or any other mortal human) and is ready to believe that the latter (the "impressor") is verily GOD, is highly gullible. Therefore, these European Sai devotees might be chanting rudram in the belief that it will bring them fulfilment of all or most of their worldly desires.

Shri Sangom,


Westerners were always ahead of we Indian in desiring and acquiring materialistic, monetary and physical pleasures. They have adopted a lot in their culture and have experienced a lot in their personal and social life. And in the process have found themselves losing their inner peace and harmony.

Now, they started valuing the spiritual energies of Hinduism and many are adopting them in their attempt to find physical, mental and psychological refinement and balance.

These westerners who throng to Sathya Sai Sang, ISKCON etc. are those who all want to achieve mental peace, mental balance and a disciplined way of life, while attempting to progress spiritually.

It would be nice if we Hindus do value and practice spirituality to the extent possible and honestly for our own betterment and collective social betterment, while striving to achieve our worldly desires.

 
Shri Sangom,


Westerners were always ahead of we Indian in desiring and acquiring materialistic, monetary and physical pleasures. They have adopted a lot in their culture and have experienced a lot in their personal and social life. And in the process have found themselves losing their inner peace and harmony.

Now, they started valuing the spiritual energies of Hinduism and many are adopting them in their attempt to find physical, mental and psychological refinement and balance.

These westerners who throng to Sathya Sai Sang, ISKCON etc. are those who all want to achieve mental peace, mental balance and a disciplined way of life, while attempting to progress spiritually.

It would be nice if we Hindus do value and practice spirituality to the extent possible and honestly for our own betterment and collective social betterment, while striving to achieve our worldly desires.


Dear Shri Ravi,

Smt. Renuka has also written more or less on the same lines as in your above-quoted post. Since both of you have much more exposure to foreigners and foreign countries, I cannot pass any value judgment on your views/observations. But I have people closely known to me who are very great devotees of iskcon, satyasaibaba, matha Amrithanandamayi etc. From my conversations with them, I get the impression that the foreign devotees (which today decides the status level of each guru) consists of different types, such as, (i) people who have some problems and believe that the said guru/organization will give them a complete cure or solution, — this is by far the largest segment, (ii) people who claim to have come to the guru/organization for their spiritual upliftment but many of these people are intimately connected with the running of the guru's ashram/organization and so there is need to be circumspect about their genuine intentions and agenda, and (iii) people who stand to benefit by the existence/continuance of the ashram/organization; examples, the shop-keepers, petty traders, auto-rikshaw wallahs/taxi-drivers, tour organizers etc.; such people generally have only business interests personally in the ashram/organization but will usually pretend to be very spiritually devoted to the ashram/organization.

Today, almost all such guruji outfits/organizations have come to possess some type of groups which act as the "big-brother" and keep a close and meticulous watch on all devotees of all the above categories. If this group gets suspicion about any devotee woe betide him/her!

In such scenario, it will be difficult to expect anyone of the foreign devotees to come out and speak his/her mind. If any foreigner really wants to benefit by Hindu spiritualism, yoga, etc., there are enough gurus abroad also and most of them have come to earn bad names! So, most of the foreigners are being lured by tour organizers under one pretext or other and being brought to these ashrams, imo. The impression that westerners have lost their mental peace and are coming to our gurus/babas/ashrams in genuine search for spiritual peace, is a ludicrous belief, but it does immense good to the cause of those foreigners!!;)
 
Dear Doctor,


BTW Magha's in his Shishupala Vada was known to have the combination of Kalidasa's appropriate similes, Bharavi's profundity of meaning and Dandin's elegance in words.


UPAMAA KAALIDASAYSA


BHAARAVEHA ARTHA GAURAVAM


DANDINAHA PADA LAALITHYAM

MAAGHE SANTHI TRAYO GUNAAHA....



उपमा कालिदासस्य

भारावे अर्थ गौरवं

दंडिना पद लालित्यं

माघे सन्ति त्रयो गुणाः
 
Last edited:
I fully agree with Madam Renuka that Sanathana Dharmam belongs to the whole Univese and it should be so.

I do NOT agree that the Westerners evince Interest for material gains.Many of them are economically very well to do and are sincerely interested to learn more..

On November 25 th-Sunday- (2012) I was travelling by Air-India -JFK to Delhi.-A young man in his middle 30s was seated next to me.He is a very well paid Softwear Engineer somewhere in California(he told me the place--I do not remember).He had come to East coast for some work and from there goes to Delhi on the way to Puri.He is a second generation Polish-American.He honestly and very sincerely believes that his GURU in Puri (Orissa) has transformed his life from almost "Nothingnes" to a very fruitful life.Economically he is very well to do and makes many trips to Puri.He is well versed in "Patanjali Yoga Sutram" -both original and translation.We had a breif discussion on one Sutram :-"Tatra Niraadhisayam Sarvgjna Bheeejam".My wife felt ,since we were in Economy class, our discussions might disturb others around.--so I discontinued.


I feel that these two groups are very sincere.
 
Dear SHri Sangom ,
whilst on the whole i agree with some pf your comments
i feel it is important for those of us that prescribe to reincarnation as Hindus to embrace the full meaning of this re There are no foreigners only the Devine simply because there is nothing in Holy Vedas to indicate anything Foreign or outside of God/ Brahma and that reincarnation has led souls into all types of bodies and nations.
It is only natural that said Devine souls would gravitate toward that which it had presently been attracted too , and that many so called Indians will be inhabiting bodies ( not foreign ) that are not " indian " into the future in greater and greater numbers as attraction to western interests and pursuits create conditions for satisfaction of these attractions and they will of course also gravitate again back to Hindu interests
devine soul is not Indian and has no race colour or creed and that leeds us to understand that many so called Indians shouldnt be so surprised to see divine inhabiting different racial bodies practising all manner of Vedic practices and that Chances are they will be next to do so
May all be warmly welcome to do so
Jai Budhi Maa !!!
 
Things to read before making up your mind on this topic

I recently joined this forum in order to provide a link to a source that presents many of our stotras in various native scripts.
I changed my mind when I saw a couple of the topics and am compelled to respond to them instead.
 
The following posts elsewhere are actually very relevant to this topic. I think the first item at least is something all Hindus should read, particularly all those here so eagerly applauding foreigners grasping at the Vedam.

1. Post 32 of india-forum.com/forums/index.php?/topic/1836-indology-and-indologists/page__view__findpost__p__96270
(where IE stands for Indo-Europeans. A post-nazi era euphemism for Aryans)
2. Post 67 of india-forum.com/forums/index.php?/topic/2027-other-natural-religions/page__view__findpost__p__106381
3. Posts 134 and 136, 137 of india-forum.com/forums/index.php?/topic/975-sanatana-dharma-aka-hinduism-3rd-bin/page__view__findpost__p__115321__s__87fbb148e95c146b561113f535f4f663
 

The context being tamil brahmins, I think the following is relevant:
I recall reading Kanchi Paramacharya state (either in his transcribed speeches or his personal writings) that the Vedas must be continued by brahmanas (invariably native, as no foreign kinds are recognised). That it was brahmanas’ imperative duty to continue the tradition, which practices were always for the benefit of all Hindu society though carried out by a few, and that other Hindus could not willy-nilly abbrogate this duty to themselves merely because brahmanas in our age had abandoned it. He encouraged all Hindus to goad Brahmanas back into Vedic learning in order to preserve this for all Hindu society and carry out Vedic practices for the benefit of all Hindus.

In all this discussion of his, it was implicit but clear that the Kanchi Paramacharya does not remotely entertain the notion that foreigners should have access to the Vedas, as he’s even saying that it’s not the duty of all native Hindus themselves (who most assuredly have rights and claims on the Vedas before any foreigners ever could). So all those who pretend to fawn over Kanchi Paramacharya can read his own works on the matter and know exactly where they should stand on the issue of foreigners’ pretences to the Vedas and on the issue of Hindus training foreigners in this matter.

While I might not follow the Kanchi Paramacharya on all matters (not knowing his views on all matters), and I personally read Yudhisthira’s description in the Mahabharatam of how the Veda is seen in all 4 Hindu varnas as an acknowledgement that the Vedas are to be at least heard if not learnt by all native Hindus, Yudhisthira too did not entertain the notion of foreigners helping themselves to the Vedas. He specifically speaks of the native Hindus, that is those whose ancestral religion this is. Also, I understand that at least some parts of the Vedam were open to a wide range of Hindu communities in the distant Hindu past, including Vanavasi Hindus.
 
Dear SHri Sangom ,
whilst on the whole i agree with some pf your comments
i feel it is important for those of us that prescribe to reincarnation as Hindus to embrace the full meaning of this re There are no foreigners only the Devine simply because there is nothing in Holy Vedas to indicate anything Foreign or outside of God/ Brahma and that reincarnation has led souls into all types of bodies and nations.
It is only natural that said Devine souls would gravitate toward that which it had presently been attracted too , and that many so called Indians will be inhabiting bodies ( not foreign ) that are not " indian " into the future in greater and greater numbers as attraction to western interests and pursuits create conditions for satisfaction of these attractions and they will of course also gravitate again back to Hindu interests
devine soul is not Indian and has no race colour or creed and that leeds us to understand that many so called Indians shouldnt be so surprised to see divine inhabiting different racial bodies practising all manner of Vedic practices and that Chances are they will be next to do so
May all be warmly welcome to do so
Jai Budhi Maa !!!

Shri Maabhakt sir,

I have a doubt, sir. If the divine is "really" one only, then why does the divine make people born in so many religious faiths some of which are in perpetual conflict with some others? Or, is the creation even beyond the reach of this divine?

How are we sure that the "indian" way is the only way to progress (whatever that may be), or, the "right path" how and why do indians go after the western interests and religion? Supposing, Jesus was, after all, right; then will it not mean that indians who get attracted to Christianity are taking the right road whereas the rudram-chanting europeans are taking the road to hell and/or eternal damnation?

Has any religion, sect, guru, godman/godwoman been able to demonstrate that the indian (hindu) religion is the "only" correct path and that all the rest are bogus?

I am interested in knowing your views, sir.
 
Hinduism never claimed to be the only way. Such statements are alien to Hinduism. Hinduism accepts All paths as Valid paths.

Unfortunately some of our sects believe that their way is the only way.


Sri. Ramakrishna said "There are As many ways as there are Men."
 
I recently joined this forum in order to provide a link to a source that presents many of our stotras in various native scripts.
I changed my mind when I saw a couple of the topics and am compelled to respond to them instead.
 
The following posts elsewhere are actually very relevant to this topic. I think the first item at least is something all Hindus should read, particularly all those here so eagerly applauding foreigners grasping at the Vedam.

1. Post 32 of india-forum.com/forums/index.php?/topic/1836-indology-and-indologists/page__view__findpost__p__96270
(where IE stands for Indo-Europeans. A post-nazi era euphemism for Aryans)
2. Post 67 of india-forum.com/forums/index.php?/topic/2027-other-natural-religions/page__view__findpost__p__106381
3. Posts 134 and 136, 137 of india-forum.com/forums/index.php?/topic/975-sanatana-dharma-aka-hinduism-3rd-bin/page__view__findpost__p__115321__s__87fbb148e95c146b561113f535f4f663
 

The context being tamil brahmins, I think the following is relevant:
I recall reading Kanchi Paramacharya state (either in his transcribed speeches or his personal writings) that the Vedas must be continued by brahmanas (invariably native, as no foreign kinds are recognised). That it was brahmanas’ imperative duty to continue the tradition, which practices were always for the benefit of all Hindu society though carried out by a few, and that other Hindus could not willy-nilly abbrogate this duty to themselves merely because brahmanas in our age had abandoned it. He encouraged all Hindus to goad Brahmanas back into Vedic learning in order to preserve this for all Hindu society and carry out Vedic practices for the benefit of all Hindus.

In all this discussion of his, it was implicit but clear that the Kanchi Paramacharya does not remotely entertain the notion that foreigners should have access to the Vedas, as he’s even saying that it’s not the duty of all native Hindus themselves (who most assuredly have rights and claims on the Vedas before any foreigners ever could). So all those who pretend to fawn over Kanchi Paramacharya can read his own works on the matter and know exactly where they should stand on the issue of foreigners’ pretences to the Vedas and on the issue of Hindus training foreigners in this matter.

While I might not follow the Kanchi Paramacharya on all matters (not knowing his views on all matters), and I personally read Yudhisthira’s description in the Mahabharatam of how the Veda is seen in all 4 Hindu varnas as an acknowledgement that the Vedas are to be at least heard if not learnt by all native Hindus, Yudhisthira too did not entertain the notion of foreigners helping themselves to the Vedas. He specifically speaks of the native Hindus, that is those whose ancestral religion this is. Also, I understand that at least some parts of the Vedam were open to a wide range of Hindu communities in the distant Hindu past, including Vanavasi Hindus.

Dear Sir,

I dont have any problems with anyone reciting the word of God cos it is only now that we are Indians..we have no idea what race we were in a previous birth or what we will be in our next life.
But as long we have the love for God we will meet Him in words of praise in our lives to come.

So those so those "foreigners" reciting Rudram/Vedas etc have earned it through merit in their previous birth.

I am sure you know very well nothing happens without the will of God..so lets not all be squirrels that hide their nuts in many places and forget where they hide it.

Hiding knowledge does not make it grow and also nothing is really ours.
Even our very existence is loaned from God.

Think about this..the next time you recite Loka Samastha Sukhino Bhavantu.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Latest ads

Back
Top