• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Gender equality? Nine laws in India that make women less equal than men

Status
Not open for further replies.

prasad1

Active member
Do current laws in India aim at equality of men and women? Though equality is one of the fundamental rights as stated in our Constitution, it is far from practice.


There are laws in our country, which clearly favour men over women, according to Quartz India. In a recent UN report on India's legal code lists, it just got official. Here are some of them:


Hindu laws of inheritance: Different religions have different inheritance laws. According to the Hindu inheritance law, the property of a woman who dies without a will is handled differently from that of a man. In the absence of spouse and children, the husband’s heirs inherit the woman’s estate.


Parsi laws of inheritance: Despite decreasing numbers in the Parsi community, those who marry outside the community are penalised. A non-parsi woman who is either a wife or a widow of a Parsi man cannot inherit. However, their children can. But again, a Parsi woman marrying a non-Parsi man cannot be considered a part of the Parsi community.


Prohibition of Child Marriage Act: The law only prohibits the marriages of children; it does not render them illegal once they actually happen. The married children, however, have the right to declare it void. A woman can call off a marriage until she turns 20, whereas a man has till age 23.


Age of consent: Sexual intercourse with a girl below the age of 18 is considered rape. But since child marriages are not illegal, a man can legally have sex with his wife even if she is a minor, as long as she is above the age of 15. Further, marital rape is still not criminalised in India.


Rape of a separated wife: The rape of a separated wife carries lesser punishment than the rape of any other woman. Forced sexual intercourse with the former is punishable with two to seven years of imprisonment. The prison sentence for the rape of any other woman ranges from seven years to life.


Marriageable age: The minimum age for marriage for a boy is 21, but 18 for a girl. This is a legal extension of the patriarchal mindset that believes that a wife should always be younger than the man.


Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act: Women are still not equal guardians of their children. A father is considered the “natural guardian” of a child, although the custody of offspring under the age of 5 will ordinarily be awarded to the mother.


The Goa Law on polygamy: A law recognises the second marriage of a “Gentile Hindu” man of Goa if his previous wife does not have any children before the age of 25 or if she does not have a male child by 30.


No right to marital property: Upon separation or divorce, an Indian woman is entitled only to maintenance from her husband. She has no right to the assets, such as house or commercial property, bought in her husband’s name during the marriage.
Gender equality? Nine laws in India that make women less equal than men
 
Gender equality? Nine laws in India that make women less equal than men

Doesn't the constitution also permit the muslims to be governed by muslim personal laws which is largely Sharia laws? Does the UN report conveniently ignore that?

[FONT=&quot]There is a deafening silence on the plight of Indian muslim women who are subjected to muslim personal laws, or Sharia laws under which they are covered.[/FONT]

[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Muslim personal laws provide an Islamic alternative to secular models of governance. Considering just the marital Rights:[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]A man is entitled to up to four wives, but a woman may only have one husband. [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]The husband pays a “bride price” ( or mahr).This “mahr” is in exchange for sexual submission (tamkin)- regarded as unconditional consent for the remainder of the marriage.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]A man can divorce his wife by making a declaration (talaq) in front of an Islamic judge irrespective of the woman's consent. Even her presence is not required. For a woman to divorce a man (khula), his consent is required.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]“Temporary marriage” (even for less than a half an hour) is allowed - A convenient rule used by Saudi and other Mid-East tourists to get temporary ‘wives’ in Hyderabad and elsewhere during their short visits to India.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]Wife beating permitted.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]There is no joint property; the man owns all property, (except for what the woman owned before the marriage).[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]There is no specific minimum age for marriage. [/FONT]
 
interesting supreme court judgement on fatwas by qazis in india
the fatwa is not legally binding according to learned judges
likely to have a storm in muslim community
 
Doesn't the constitution also permit the muslims to be governed by muslim personal laws which is largely Sharia laws? Does the UN report conveniently ignore that?


Why do we keep bringing Muslim or Christian practice or law in this site.
I can understand sometimes we have present the muslim pov to contrast with Hindu or our own POV. 99.9999% of people on this site are Hindus, and most of them are south Indian, and probably Born Brahmin.
If a position is expressed here, it is by a Hindu about Hindus (exceptions are there). So instead of giving opinion about that why point out the treatment of natives in Brazil, or Muslim in India, or Chinese in 18th century US. That is just red herring, people are trying to divert attention away from the problem in their own backyard.

I can not change the Muslim Law, I doubt even your Champion is going to touch that. So what is the point?

Just because Hindus in Pakistan or Saudi do not have the freedom to practice Hinduism, are you suggesting that in India we should reciprocate that.

So please stop throwing up this wall. We should change what can be changed for our own people. How it affects others is their problem.
 
prasadji
it is wonderful to talk of genderr inequality for ladies
you know 3,31700 plus cases have been filed by married ladies against inlaws {498A non bailable, criminal]against old mother in laws, SIL out of which 317000 odds are likely to be thrown ie the cases are without basis and only to settle scores with husbands . the balance cases might be genuine
20 percent jailed in women wards in tihar jail are these poor relatives of husbands . these are called saas-nannad cells . ladies are settling scores with a vengeance. cases filed are non bailable . lawyers of married women having disputes with husband foist false cases on husbands relatives . police simply arrest these ladies on complaint by married ladies and jail them after cursory investigation. recently supreme court judges have cautioned police against this summary arrests and not arrest anyone without valid and prosecutable evidence
most men officers in all offices are careful in dealing with lady employees after hue and cry about workplace harassment. any male can easily get framed by ladies . often false complaints are lodged if the ladies are denied their promotion/rewards at the work place in govt offices.
most know which male officers are vulnerable due to their past conduct. the unkind bosses get this treatment for settling scores at promotion time.lol
 
Why do we keep bringing Muslim or Christian practice or law in this site.

Stay cool Sir! I thought you were reporting a UN/ Amnesty report on India and Indians, not just on Hindus. And the report mentions Parsis! The title of the thread is: Gender equality? Nine laws in India that make women less equal than men

and not

Gender equality? Nine laws in India that make Hindu women less equal than Hindu men


 
Last edited:
prasadji
it is wonderful to talk of genderr inequality for ladies
you know 3,31700 plus cases have been filed by married ladies against inlaws {498A non bailable, criminal]against old mother in laws, SIL out of which 317000 odds are likely to be thrown ie the cases are without basis and only to settle scores with husbands . the balance cases might be genuine
20 percent jailed in women wards in tihar jail are these poor relatives of husbands . these are called saas-nannad cells . ladies are settling scores with a vengeance. cases filed are non bailable . lawyers of married women having disputes with husband foist false cases on husbands relatives . police simply arrest these ladies on complaint by married ladies and jail them after cursory investigation. recently supreme court judges have cautioned police against this summary arrests and not arrest anyone without valid and prosecutable evidence
most men officers in all offices are careful in dealing with lady employees after hue and cry about workplace harassment. any male can easily get framed by ladies . often false complaints are lodged if the ladies are denied their promotion/rewards at the work place in govt offices.
most know which male officers are vulnerable due to their past conduct. the unkind bosses get this treatment for settling scores at promotion time.lol

yes I agree, that there has been misuse of Dowry law by women. The SC also took note of this.
 
I think the main issue is that of women's education. It is not easy to exploit an educated woman. Generally in the south, west and east women are treated better than in Hindi belt.
 
Laws can never instil equality between men and women. Laws will benefit only the lawyers whose livelihood depends on the application of laws into every sphere of life. Many of our behaviours were fashioned right from the time of our monkey-ancestors͵ which is why we often dont recognize how well entrenched they are. Proper awareness campaigns is the need of the hour͵ not laws
 
I think the main issue is that of women's education. It is not easy to exploit an educated woman.

Dear Biswa Mahodaya,

After many years of living in this world and dealing with humans on daily basis I have come to a conclusion that intelligence or stupidity has very little to do with education.

So its not that an educated woman is difficult to exploit..sometime you would be surprised how gullible some educated women can be.It all depends on the mindset.
 
Dear Biswa Mahodaya,

After many years of living in this world and dealing with humans on daily basis I have come to a conclusion that intelligence or stupidity has very little to do with education.

So its not that an educated woman is difficult to exploit..sometime you would be surprised how gullible some educated women can be.It all depends on the mindset.
education leads to empowerment of women.educated women can become economic entities in their own right.

if a woman wants to be exploited by choice due to an outdated mindset not many can help her.

majority of educated and working women can and do strive for equality at the homefront . some of course become

excessively dependent on spouses and get badly treated
 
Last edited:
Laws can never instil equality between men and women. Laws will benefit only the lawyers whose livelihood depends on the application of laws into every sphere of life. Many of our behaviours were fashioned right from the time of our monkey-ancestors͵ which is why we often dont recognize how well entrenched they are. Proper awareness campaigns is the need of the hour͵ not laws
it is quite true that our older generation instills and nurtures inequality of sexes in younger generation based on their experience and so women start with a disadvantage. They start believing that the have to play an inferior role subordinate to their spouses. academic education empowers them to some extent. but a deeply entrenched mindset
not believing in their own self worth is a real issue
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top