• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

How to reframe Dharma in modern language?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Refreshing reading. I am for using words like dharma, murti, punya, moksha etc. instead of inadequate english translations. Full article link at the bottom.

"World Hindu Youth (WHY) association hosted a seminar on “Reframing Bharat” followed by another on a “New vocabulary to describe Vedic dharma” on Saturday, April 20, 2013, at Chinmaya Mission Badri campus located at 11S080 Kingery Hwy, Willowbrook, IL 60527. Presented by best-selling author Jeffrey Armstrong, from Vancouver.

"The seminars aim to teach the younger generation how to speak confidently about Hindu dharma especially to its detractors.

"
Youth are especially vulnerable because the parents are not equipped to translate their beliefs into language that makes sense within the worldview and language acquired here through schooling.

Metaphor:
When asked “why do you Hindus have so many gods?” we could start talking about the icons on his desktop and compare them to “idols” that are different from programs, yet help keeps things organized, etc., point out that invoking the name of the god is like clicking on the icon to accomplish a task through the underlying code.
"Pitfalls of mapping familiar Western concepts to Hindu traditional terminology. Armstrong explained why dharma is not religion, Bhagavan is not God, yoga is not faith, devas are not gods, murthis are not idols, namah is not worship, papa is not sin, svarga is not heaven, and other such facile equivalences.

"
Armstrong also attacked the “sameness” syndrome preached by many Hindus. All religions are not the same but more akin competing operating systems, like Microsoft Windows versus Apple, each with its own terminology and underlying philosophy. The Christian operating system is much poorer in vocabulary, as evidenced by the smaller list of words to avoid. The British purposely replaced Sanskrit with English language, thereby limiting the vocabulary for discourse about oneself.

Jeffrey Armstrong Teaches Native-Born Hindus How to Reframe Dharma | Asian Media USA
 
Modi slams politicians for ignoring Indian culture

Narendra Modi's speech while inaugurating a youth training centre of Brahma Kumaris in Ahmedabad on Sunday, 21st April

"
Emphasising the need to inculcate values in youth to control social evils, traditional Indian value-based systems have been painted in "secular" and "non-secular" garb.

"To save society from such evils
recent crimes against women, we should inculcate Indian values and culture in our youth."

"However, in these times, value-based education systems like yoga are being weighed in terms of secularism and non-secularism."

"Politicians involved in vote-bank politics have committed a sin by ignoring Indian culture. History will seek answers from them," he said.

Modi slams politicians for ignoring Indian culture - Hindustan Times

 
Refreshing reading. I am for using words like dharma, murti, punya, moksha etc. instead of inadequate english translations. Full article link at the bottom.

"World Hindu Youth (WHY) association hosted a seminar on “Reframing Bharat” followed by another on a “New vocabulary to describe Vedic dharma” on Saturday, April 20, 2013, at Chinmaya Mission Badri campus located at 11S080 Kingery Hwy, Willowbrook, IL 60527. Presented by best-selling author Jeffrey Armstrong, from Vancouver.

"The seminars aim to teach the younger generation how to speak confidently about Hindu dharma especially to its detractors.

"
Youth are especially vulnerable because the parents are not equipped to translate their beliefs into language that makes sense within the worldview and language acquired here through schooling.

Metaphor:
When asked “why do you Hindus have so many gods?” we could start talking about the icons on his desktop and compare them to “idols” that are different from programs, yet help keeps things organized, etc., point out that invoking the name of the god is like clicking on the icon to accomplish a task through the underlying code.
"Pitfalls of mapping familiar Western concepts to Hindu traditional terminology. Armstrong explained why dharma is not religion, Bhagavan is not God, yoga is not faith, devas are not gods, murthis are not idols, namah is not worship, papa is not sin, svarga is not heaven, and other such facile equivalences.

"
Armstrong also attacked the “sameness” syndrome preached by many Hindus. All religions are not the same but more akin competing operating systems, like Microsoft Windows versus Apple, each with its own terminology and underlying philosophy. The Christian operating system is much poorer in vocabulary, as evidenced by the smaller list of words to avoid. The British purposely replaced Sanskrit with English language, thereby limiting the vocabulary for discourse about oneself.

Jeffrey Armstrong Teaches Native-Born Hindus How to Reframe Dharma | Asian Media USA

Dharma is Sanskrit for Law of God. In English language there is no equalent word for Dharma since the Englih speaking race were never aware of existence of God, were not spiritual, were not intellectuals who could think beyond the natural, physical realm. In fact the ancient English speaking race were not civilized, were not cultured until they were conquered by the Gauls and hence mixed with the Gauls. The concept of God entered England only after the invasion of England by Julius Ceasar posterior to which the Roman religion was introduced. However the Roman religion did not take much roots since it was outshadowed by Roman Catholicism which however took roots in England to be replaced by Protestantism following the outbreak of Reformation Movement.

We Indians are intellectuals enough and we don't need a foreigner to teach us about Dharma. Nevertheless the Law of God is Absolute and Eternal and it is insanity to attempt reframing of Dharma.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Latest ads

Back
Top