• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Immigration officer plays moral police, asks woman why she was travelling alone Manju

Status
Not open for further replies.

prasad1

Active member
An immigration officer at Mumbai airport played Taliban-style moral police recently, questioning a woman on why she was travelling alone. Worse, he held that if she had been allowed to go backpacking alone, her family background was questionable.


Two months ago, a 21-year old Indian woman planning to backpack across Europe had the misfortune of walking up to this officer's desk and facing a barrage of uncomfortable questions to clear immigration. She was due to board a flight to Abu Dhabi from where she had to take a connecting flight to Paris.


"I was not only treated rudely, but also insulted and humiliated. In the end, before stamping my passport, he said that I should not go crying to the Indian embassy if something untoward happened to me," said Aditi Prakash (name changed on request).

Immigration officer plays moral police, asks woman why she was travelling alone - The Times of India

Why am I not surprised?

Recounting her ordeal Aditi said, "He asked me why I was travelling alone and when Ireplied that I am a 21-year-old adult and I can travel alone, he said women should not. He said he would have posed this question to even a 50-year-old woman if she were travelling alone." She added, "When I asked him why he didn't question the male passengers, he said that my job was to answer questions and not to ask them."


The officer then went on to interrogate her about her backpacking trip. He wanted to know how her parents could let her travel alone. He inquired about their profession. The girl had lost her father and her mother is a teacher. He asked how her family got the money for the trip. Her motives for the trip were questioned . He also wondered whether her parents were "respectable people" as they had allowed her to travel alone.
 
Obviously, the immigration officer should not play God, and perhaps this woman was the wrong target. But you know, human trafficking happens, from India mostly to the Middle East. Of course in many of those cases the accompanying male pretends to be the husband.
 
From the same news:

Harassed woman flyer files complaint, probe underway

An immigration officer has the job of finding out whether people are being trafficked, whether people of other nationalities who have similar ethinicities have procured an Indian passport and are using it illegally and so on. So, the line of questioning depends on a passenger's profile, the travel experience shown in the passport, the country they are flying to and so on. In recent past, following a round of questioning, an immigration officer found that two women with a man (who claimed to be their relative) were actually being trafficked.
 
I just find this so sexist! Granted, human trafficking does happen, but his line of questioning borders on the offensive.Maybe such officers need to be trained in handling passengers with greter sensitivity.
 
From the same news:


Do you recollect the newspaper reports or hyperlinks of Shah Rukh Khan detained about two times, detention of Union Minister Praful Patel and Former president Abdul Kalam by U S immigration officials in these columns in the past?
 
Zebraji,
I do not think you got the gist of the OP.
It is highhandedness of the officer and in association to his moral objection to a single girl traveling alone. The patronizing and condensing tone of the comment.

I expected that it is not unique to this officer, even though it is wrong.
 
To me, the officer appears downright sexist. Granted, human trafficking does happen, and he is entirely within his right to question the woman, but his line of questioning is very offensive. He needs some lessons in customer service to handle such cases with greater sensitivity.
 
Immigration officers love to pick and choose anyone to question I feel.

Enough times in India the person in front of me just gets his/her passport stamped and no questions asked.

Even my husband never gets asked any question but when it is my turn..I get asked all sorts of questions every time without fail.. like "give the date of your last visit to India and where you went last year..where you stayed last year..when are you planning to come back to India again..you look familiar..I have seen you somewhere before" believe me all sorts of questions are asked..I just answer what ever is asked.

You see sometimes we do not really remember when we came last as in exact date so now I make sure I write down all previous flights detail in a note book cos I know some immigration guy will ask me something.

Even when going back to Malaysia ..Indian immigration will ask before letting you through "so when are you planning to come back here again"

When I tell them 'I dont know yet?"

They will reply "Why???you don't like India...you should come here more often etc"

So best is to smile to these guys as not antagonize them...cos who cares what they ask as long they stamp my passport and let me in or out!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top