• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Nobler than a Nobel

Status
Not open for further replies.

prasad1

Active member
The_Hindu :ARUNA SANKARANARAYANAN

What dictates your life choices? Trophies, awards, public recognition? Or a desire to excel, fuelled by passion?


Degrees, awards, honours, titles and Who’s Who lists occupy a pre-eminent position in the Indian psyche. While we prize accolades and flaunt laurels won by Indians, especially those bestowed by foreign hands, we define ‘success’ in very narrow terms. During a child’s scholastic career, success is synonymous with marks a student obtains. However, even in adulthood, we continue to place a premium on external indices. The number of zeroes in a person’s salary is directly proportional to a person’s status in our social hierarchy. ‘Success’ in our country is synonymous with public recognition, and, at times, even adulation. By thus paying tribute to achievement, we fail to nurture genuine passions and intrinsic drives. We motivate children to succeed by conventional standards, but do not necessarily inspire them to excel.
..........

Thus, youngsters who are at a fork road in their lives should extricate themselves from societal straitjackets that force them to select courses based on “what people will say.” Instead, students should reflect on their signature strengths and interests and pursue courses and careers that they find intrinsically fulfilling. Educators and parents also have to make a concerted effort to cultivate a conducive climate where students do not feel the need to ask, “What must we do to win a Nobel?”


The author is the Director, PRAYATNA.
 
The problem with implementing the author's suggestions is that the system itself is achievement centric. For example, you cannot become an expert in mathematics or physics without improving on or ultimately bringing down another man's thesis. The system is bottom up and we have to learn to live with it. Also, a passion or a desire may not be a genuine wish of a child but usually thrust upon by the elders.

But something can be done by figuring out objectively the real aptitude of the child.
 
Mr. Sravna,
Your point is well made.
The problem of our generation was that the choices we had was limited, and we could guide our children with the fields we knew.
In todays world the choices are many. In USA the undergrad students can change their field of study at any time. In India in my time you are classified as art, science, or commerce very early in studies and then you are straitjacketed in that field. At that age generally we do not know our passions.

A profession like medicine or research you should not get into to make money, you must have passion for the profession. Other fields you can get by even if you came into the field by accident. I came into business by accident and found out that I am good at it, even though I was an engineer.
 
A profession like medicine or research you should not get into to make money, you must have passion for the profession
Dear Mr.Prasad, if you remember a month or so back you had started a thread wherein none of the the Indian Universities were not appearing in the top ones list. This is in direct relation to that also. Medical profession is the biggest money spinner here. Our govt is projecting our high class Hospitals as tourist/Health destinations. Passion for the profession will be a big zero for Sons/Daughters of the Doctors, already built a dispensary/clinic/hospital. He/she has to take over & run the show.For that they need Medical degree whatever may be the cost.
Students with Passion only can stand outside the medical college and look at the building only!!
Good, that the profession you took by chance, has made you love that & be successsful. This is like deeply Love with wife after marriage and not a love marriage!!
Cheers.
 
Prasad Sir

You say that you should not get into medicine for the money, but in the US isn't medicine the most highly paid field. Correct me if I'm wrong, but i'm pretty sure it is.
 
A profession like medicine or research you should not get into to make money, you must have passion for the profession.

Dear Prasad ji,

One should not be money minded when one is a doctor but one needs to earn a living too.
We doctors also need money to pay our nurses and pay our bills to pharma companies.

The reason I became a doctor is becos I wanted to be self employed and it gives a steady decent income.
One can still earn money the Dharmic way.

In fact my passion was for animals and my 1st choice was to be a Vet but I decided to do medicine instead.


Payment is just a reaction to the action of treatment rendered by a doctor to a patient.

There are many doctors who are not money minded but earn really well and are rich cos they are good in their work and have many patients.

Coming to passion for profession it waxes and wanes like the moon..on some days we doctors might not even feel like seeing patients but still drag ourselves to work.

A doc friend of mine was so sick and tired of seeing patients non stop that he took up mountain climbing as a hobby and was just back from Nepal yesterday.
He closes his practice for weeks sometimes.

He said seeing patients regularly can make one sick too.

Another doc I know closed his clinic (retired at 60) and is just working some short hours at some medical centre and he has enrolled for a MA degree in Vedic Studies and Hinduism.
He goes around on weekends giving Geeta lectures here.

He also said..one can never see patients forever.
 
Last edited:
Prasad Sir

You say that you should not get into medicine for the money, but in the US isn't medicine the most highly paid field. Correct me if I'm wrong, but i'm pretty sure it is.

It is a high paid profession,but people in finance, business, and various fields make lot more money very early. For a highly paid medical doctor has to put in 12 years before they can be specialist. A finance major working for a brokerage will start earning 10 years head start,

What I meant was money alone should not be the motive for going in profession of medicine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top