• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Reservation fallout: Deccan College

Status
Not open for further replies.
[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]The Deccan College in Pune is the third oldest educational institution in the country. Stretching back to the Dakshina Fund started by Khanderao Dabhade, a Maratha Sardar and continued by the Peshwas for propagating learning, the Dakshina Fund was given the status of an institution named as the Hindoo College on 6th October 1821 (Vijayadasami day).[/FONT]
[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]2. It has three departments; archaeology, linguistics and samskrit lexicography.
3. Teaching faculty in SC/ST categories is mostly unfilled for the last 33 years.
4. In the samskrit/lexicography department, 2 posts for professor, 3 for asst. professors are lying vacant for the past 33 years.
4. In the linguistics and archaeology departments for 4 reserved posts in each are lying vacant for past 33 years.
5. Despite regular multiple advertisements, no one from the reserved category applies. According to rules, open category candidates cannot be considered even if the reserved vacancies are unfilled.
6. More complicated conditions; the expert in any field should also be a domicile of maharashtra in addition to reserve category. For eg. the expert in dravidian language, though likely to be from south, must be a resident of maharashtra and be a BC. Reader in sindhi, reserved for OBC cannot be filled because there are no OBC sindhis in maharashtra.
7. In case of students also, the situation is grave. For the non-commercial subjects - samskrit and linguistics, not a single student from the reserved category. The bright side, even non reserved seats are not filled; so no loss for the non BC students.
8. In archaeology too, 10 students joined in the reserved category for M.A., but only 2 remained in the second year. Scholarship and free hostel has not attracted BC students.

Vicious circle - no students and so no future teachers. What is the solution?

Abolish reservation and open up facilities and opportunities for all.
[/FONT]
 
hi
just info...my professor studied in deccan in linguistics dept very long back...i know the college in pune....ferguson /decaan

colleges are oldest in maharastra...may be in india....
 
The Deccan College in Pune is the third oldest educational institution in the country. Stretching back to the Dakshina Fund started by Khanderao Dabhade, a Maratha Sardar and continued by the Peshwas for propagating learning, the Dakshina Fund was given the status of an institution named as the Hindoo College on 6th October 1821 (Vijayadasami day).
.
6. More complicated conditions; the expert in any field should also be a domicile of maharashtra in addition to reserve category. For eg. the expert in dravidian language, though likely to be from south, must be a resident of maharashtra and be a BC. Reader in sindhi, reserved for OBC cannot be filled because there are no OBC sindhis in maharashtra.
Vicious circle - no students and so no future teachers. What is the solution?

.

This does not show the effect of reservation. But of Regional/Linguistic Chauvinism. The posts would have been filled long back if they had allowed qualified people from all over India to apply.

In the land of Tilak and Gokale, regional/linguistic chauvinism rule the roost now.

The biggest blunder of Independent India was the creation of Linguistic states.
 
Last edited:
Discrimination in any form is bad. Discrimination based on language, region, colour , race and of course Caste.

Such discrimination goes on and is sanctioned by legislatures.

Problem with the so called intellectuals is that they are raising protests about discrimination based on caste, sex. But we in India seem to implicitly accept and endorse discrimination based on Region, Language and Faith (sect).

This has resulted in Scholars going abroad. A Sanskrit Scholar from Tamil Nadu will not get a Job in other states. In some states he will not get it because the Institution which employs him gives jobs only to a particular sect.

But he may land a job in Harvard university.

This is the main reason for Scholars in Hinduism going for positions in the Universities in U.S.

There you are accepted for your knowledge of Hinduism.

But in India your acceptance depends on your caste, Region, Sect and language.

U.S the most religious country in the world, accepts Hindu scholars who would never find acceptance in India.

Our Academic community is part of these discriminations which is clearly shown by the above report. We would close the college rather than employ a non-Maharashtrians. This happens all over India.

GOD Save India.
 
Chauvinism of different hues is also a manifestation of underlying hatred. Unfortunately hatred sells fast. All politicians who want quickly travel the political miles catches a hatred vehicle and get themselves kicked afar. They are able to cover a large distance quickly with this vehicle as was evidenced in history by Hitler, mussolini, our own EVR and Company, Bal Takre of Maharashtra and many others. Language Chauvinism is an opiate which is used to rally people on the basis of language. If we have Deccan college vacancies unfilled for decades, we also have learned people in Tamilnadu saying that the Grantha Lipis (ஷ, ஹ, ஜ, க்ஷ,ஸ, ஸ்ரீ) should not be included while allotting fonts in unicode for Tamil-as if these letters are all belonging to some strange north Indian language. We are ready to lose the knowledge that is available that can be disseminated by using these letters. Knowledge is not important, Chauvinism is important. The imaginary pride and pristine purity of a language(whatever it means) is more important than spreading of knowledge.

We can only say "Cry the Beloved Country" .
 
Last edited:
Sri. Raju,

Discrimination and linguistic fanaticism is not restricted to politicians. You see it everywhere.

Sri Ramakrishna Mission runs many colleges in Bengal including two deemed Universities. Last year when they advertised for Professors in Sanskrit, they had included a clause "should be able to teach in Bengali." The medium of instruction being English why this clause? To keep out Non_Bengalis.

I have seen religious institutions, Maths, Ashrams and charitable institutions practicing this kind of Bengali, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam chauvinism. They do not have to win elections. But they do it.

At the same time if a White man/woman applies for the post I am sure all of them will rush to find a way to make an exception.

That is Life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Latest ads

Back
Top