• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Superstitions in India

Status
Not open for further replies.

prasad1

Active member
Published by ©Kamaal Nishant©

Superstitions are deep-rooted, unreasonable and irrational beliefs, which have no profundity. Still, superstitions are the legacy of every civilization and are inherited by the succeeding generations. It was once believed that superstitions could be rooted out with the spread of education. But these have continued to linger with us through the generations.
Superstitions originated, perhaps, when man was at the mercy of the natural elements. He held them in awe. He respected and worshipped the forces of nature like the sun, the moon, wind and water. He worshipped fire because of its destructive ability. When man started falling prey to diseases he started appeasing the gods with offerings, prayers, penances and sacrifices to ward off evil spirits. It is difficult to use the word superstition unless in an objective manner. Encyclopedia Britannica classifies superstitions into three categories: religious, cultural and personal.


Most of the religious superstitions originate as a set of peripheral beliefs often closely associated with religious principles. One problem arising from this is that followers of one particular religion might think that the rituals followed by the believer of another religion is a superstition and vice versa. Atheists may consider all religious beliefs as superstitions.


Cultural superstitions often overlap with the religious ones. Being wary of an evil eye, believing in the power of amulets, foretelling future, afraid of ill omens - all these are considered to be superstitions which are a part of our culture. These superstitions might be regional or universal. A third category is that of personal superstitions. Beliefs like wearing a particular color or writing with a particular pen will bring good luck are examples of such personal superstitions.


All civilizations have their respective superstitions. But beliefs in ghosts, sorcery, witchcraft and spirits are universal. The western civilization, although very progressive, have their own superstitions. The number '13' is considered to be unlucky in the West because at the Last Supper, Lord Jesus dined with his twelve disciples and was later crucified. Salt was spilled on the table on which they dined and, therefore, even now spilling of salt is considered ominous.


New England in America was infamous for its witches. All women, who were suspected of practicing witchcraft, were tied to a stack and burnt alive. Later, it was realized that such executions were carried out at the behest of some people who had some selfish motives.


In India too, we are confronted by a number of superstitions. A cat crossing one's path, the sight of a Brahmin or a sneeze means the purpose of the journey, which was being undertaken would remain unaccomplished. Hooting of an owl and howling of a dog augurs an impending death or doom. Contracting chickenpox is considered to be the wrath of a goddess. So, the goddess is appeased with offerings.


As we progress scientifically, it is necessary for us to understand whether there is any scientific reason behind these superstitions. One has to look up for some rationality in the superstition, being followed. A cat crossing one's path near one's home means that one should check one's kitchen. A sneeze could mean the onset of cold, so one should take some precautions.


Superstitions can sometimes lead to horrifying crimes. Instances of child sacrifices as a part of superstitious beliefs have been on the rise. In 2003, Uttar Pradesh alone reported 25 such cases till October.


Experiments are on to find out that whether man has a soul, which leaves him when he dies. People are said to have confronted ghosts and apparitions at palaces. But it remains to be proved that ghosts do exist and possess the power, they are supposed to have. Dogs are very sensitive to changes around them. They become restless before the onset of a natural calamity and wait to inform their masters of the impending doom. So, one cannot totally reject this superstition which is backed by scientific reasoning. In south India, people bathe in the morning and apply sandalwood paste on their forehead. People have now realized that sandalwood keeps the forehead cool and soothes the brain and hence, the practice has been there since time immemorial.


In today's scientific world, it is necessary that we do not blindly follow all the superstitions that were passed on to us by our ancestors. We are modem, both in our outlook and the age we are in. Therefore, we should have a judicious approach and look for some logical reason behind every superstition. We would, then, be able to give up those superstitions which have no rationality and application in today's life. It is only in this way that we can lead normal lives, befitting the citizens of the scientific era.


Source: An article published in "Wisdom" magazine in July, 2008 by Rahul Raj

I know one poster has been posting such 'gooble-de-gook' (thanks AMji for correct spelling) as learned postings in this site. Some others have termed it as researched writings. Let us step back and try to find logical reason and debunk all these useless 'gooble-de-gook'.
 
. . . In south India, people bathe in the morning and apply sandalwood paste on their forehead. People have now realized that sandalwood keeps the forehead cool and soothes the brain and hence, the practice has been there since time immemorial.

I agree with the overall sense of the OP, but in regard to the above part, I feel it is over-generalization. Only a small part of the population used to apply pure sandalwood paste on their foreheads and that too as a small circle or line. Again we have no scientific evidence to suupport the conclusions that "sandalwood keeps the forehead cool and soothes the brain", etc. Hence, if we proceed on similar lines of 'rational' arguments, we may make a complete circle and eventually justify almost all the existing group superstitions as different from personal ones.

But it is a good start, I think.
 
Superstition is all over the World, why single out India?

Some suppositious belief around the World

Cats seem to play an important role in Dutch superstitions. A black cat crossing your car is supposed to bring on something bad during your journey – if you have seen one, being more cautious on road is the only solution.

• Break a mirror, 7 years bad luck
• Never walk under a ladder
• If you spill salt, you have to toss some over your left shoulder
• Never leave a hat on a bed
• Never let a black cat cross your path
• You never say “good luck” to an actor or actress before a performance; you say “break a leg”
• Don’t give money on Mondays – you will give money all week long.

• Don’t sit at the corner of a table if you are not married yet; if you do, there are chances you will never marry

• Don’t sit at the corner of a table if you are not married yet; if you do, there are chances you will never marry.

• If your left palm itches, you will receive money; if you’re right palm itches, you will give money.

• You must wear something red in order not to be touched by an evil eye.

Superstitions around the world | PocketCultures


The growing FIFA fever across the nation gave another angle to the rising superstition. Paul, the octopus becomes global celebrity.

Octopus Paul's predictions: Superstition or something else
 
Superstition is all over the World, why single out India?

Some suppositious belief around the World

Cats seem to play an important role in Dutch superstitions. A black cat crossing your car is supposed to bring on something bad during your journey – if you have seen one, being more cautious on road is the only solution.

• Break a mirror, 7 years bad luck
• Never walk under a ladder
• If you spill salt, you have to toss some over your left shoulder
• Never leave a hat on a bed
• Never let a black cat cross your path
• You never say “good luck” to an actor or actress before a performance; you say “break a leg”
• Don’t give money on Mondays – you will give money all week long.

• Don’t sit at the corner of a table if you are not married yet; if you do, there are chances you will never marry

• Don’t sit at the corner of a table if you are not married yet; if you do, there are chances you will never marry.

• If your left palm itches, you will receive money; if you’re right palm itches, you will give money.

• You must wear something red in order not to be touched by an evil eye.

Superstitions around the world | PocketCultures


The growing FIFA fever across the nation gave another angle to the rising superstition. Paul, the octopus becomes global celebrity.

Octopus Paul's predictions: Superstition or something else

Are you saying that Ignorance is prevalent throughout the world, so we should accept it and not educate ourselves.
 
My post did not say "we should accept it and not educate our selve"

Sir,
Read your post again please.
By pointing out that others are equally at fault are you not condoning the Superstition in India? I do not care how others are superstitious why should we be superstitious is my question. I do not play games, my points are direct so let us not play games here. Are you supporting superstitions or are you for scientific explanations?
 
I agree with the overall sense of the OP, but in regard to the above part, I feel it is over-generalization. Only a small part of the population used to apply pure sandalwood paste on their foreheads and that too as a small circle or line. Again we have no scientific evidence to suupport the conclusions that "sandalwood keeps the forehead cool and soothes the brain", etc. Hence, if we proceed on similar lines of 'rational' arguments, we may make a complete circle and eventually justify almost all the existing group superstitions as different from personal ones.

But it is a good start, I think.

I agree with you 100%.
I was trying to wean people away from superstitions by conceding to keep some of them.
You are suggesting a quitting it cold turkey.
 
Sir,
Read your post again please.
By pointing out that others are equally at fault are you not condoning the Superstition in India? I do not care how others are superstitious why should we be superstitious is my question. I do not play games, my points are direct so let us not play games here. Are you supporting superstitions or are you for scientific explanations?


Sir

Your OP seems to point out that only in India Superstition is widely prevalent whereas as in many Parts of the World this is even worst; I do not support any form of superstition.
 
Sir,
The first 5 paragraphs of my post#1 deals with world wide superstations.
Only in Para 6 it points to India.
So please read my original post again.
 
hmmm, interesting article. There are superstitions in every culture, eventhough xtianity and islam have vehemently opposed superstition, still there are pre-christian and pre-islamic superstitions deeply rooted in their cultures.

As for "ghosts", till now, i do not believe that ghosts do exist for ive not seen any with my own eyes. but ive heard eyewitness accounts of black magic and spirit possession which i find difficult to dismiss altogether.
 
I will share one funny story...once I had to give my cousin some money and I had gone to her house and I told her I am in a hurry to get to work so wait at the gate and I will give her the money.

She said "Akka when one is supposed to receive money from anyone..the person giving the money should come into the house and give the money...it is not good to give money outside of the house"

I was in a real hurry and I was getting impatient and I told her "When you go to withdraw money from ATM ....you are outside the house isn't it? Why that time you don't ask the ATM to come to your house??"
 
To the OP:

There are some sweeping generalization in the post that needs addressing:

Myth 1: The current world is "modern" and "scientific" and hence more rational. This is absolutely wrong. I do not know from where this conclusion has come from. Please justify. (it is another topic as to what really "modern" and "scientific" is)
Myth 2: That anything that has been practised for a long time is "old", "superstitious" and "irrational". Wrong again. Maybe it is our "modern" mind that cannot see the "rationality" behind anything that is not "materialistic".
Myth 3: That all beliefs that cannot be explained by our "rational" mind are "superstitious" and is harmful to the development of ones intellect. One has seen intellects of both the kind; one who swears by his atheism/agnosticism and the one who smears large amounts of "sacred ash" over his forehead. Does it make one's intellect inferior to anothers?
Myth 4: That by showing one opposition to the so called "superstition", one somehow becomes the better intellect. I guess it needs no explanation.

Instead of attempting this oposition why don't the intellectuals teach values that promote compassion and empathy towards human and nature. Oh, may be it is not fasionable.

Vijay
 
Most of the religious superstitions originate as a set of peripheral beliefs often closely associated with religious principles. One problem arising from this is that followers of one particular religion might think that the rituals followed by the believer of another religion is a superstition and vice versa. Atheists may consider all religious beliefs as superstitions.

In India too, we are confronted by a number of superstitions. A cat crossing one's path, the sight of a Brahmin or a sneeze means the purpose of the journey, which was being undertaken would remain unaccomplished. Hooting of an owl and howling of a dog augurs an impending death or doom. Contracting chickenpox is considered to be the wrath of a goddess. So, the goddess is appeased with offerings.

Superstitions can sometimes lead to horrifying crimes. Instances of child sacrifices as a part of superstitious beliefs have been on the rise. In 2003, Uttar Pradesh alone reported 25 such cases till October.

Experiments are on to find out that whether man has a soul, which leaves him when he dies. People are said to have confronted ghosts and apparitions at palaces. But it remains to be proved that ghosts do exist and possess the power, they are supposed to have. Dogs are very sensitive to changes around them. They become restless before the onset of a natural calamity and wait to inform their masters of the impending doom. So, one cannot totally reject this superstition which is backed by scientific reasoning. In south India, people bathe in the morning and apply sandalwood paste on their forehead. People have now realized that sandalwood keeps the forehead cool and soothes the brain and hence, the practice has been there since time immemorial.

I know one poster has been posting such 'gooble-de-gook' (thanks AMji for correct spelling) as learned postings in this site. Some others have termed it as researched writings. Let us step back and try to find logical reason and debunk all these useless 'gooble-de-gook'.

Once there is a scientific reasoning it is no longer a superstition. Many Hindu beliefs could be labeled as superstitions.

Normally the reasoning is very simple. When one does it, it is a belief. When some one else does it, it is superstition.

Where do we draw the line? Child sacrifices are horrible and should never be allowed to happen. But the basic belief behind the Child sacrifices does not change. Child Sacrifices have been replaced by Shaving one's head. But the principle is the same. When one breaks a Pumpkin in front of a shop with red kumkum, it is the same belief which is also behind Child sacrifice. When we say "Balim Baksha, Mama Kulam raksha" we are subscribing to the same belief.

How do we deal with such a situation. We have found a substitute for Child and other sacrifices, but continue with the basic belief of sacrifice.

I have found that most of the journalists conceal an attack on Hinduism as an attack on Superstitions.

Almost all the Hindu beliefs could be classified as Superstitions.
 
Last edited:
Another angle to superstitions:

Prelude: Superstitions are for those who believe in them. Those who do not believe forget the superstitions and go your way. Thank you.

• Break a mirror, 7 years bad luck--
So do not break the mirror. A mirror once broken is totally useless.

• Never walk under a ladder--
So that you don't look up.

• Never leave a hat on a bed--
Human hair can attract, collect and retain a lot of bacteria and other germs for two reasons.1. It can quickly charge itself electrostatically 2.It has in its stem minute sacks (bag like) which can collect and retain dangerous germs. It can maintain its temperature in which the germs can multiply comfortably. The same is logic why we use wool in winter-the air bags keeps you warm. So don't leave the hat which can have hairs strands sticking to it on the bed and contaminate.

• If your left palm itches, you will receive money; if you’re right palm itches, you will give money.

Easy way to remember. No need to diarise anywhere. You can be prompt in your payments and also the receivables.

 
Last edited:
Two of my favourites, actually one of them is probably sensible advice rather than superstition especially in the old days with no electricity and stuff.

First one : My mum insists we never cut nails at night, dusk and/or twilight. Same with sweeping floors in the night evening (something about bad luck)

Second one: My friends used to tell me that ladies and women indisposed if they must walk about or go out at night/dusk to always carry an iron key or pin in their hands! I know iron is important for health but have been fascinated by this one.
 
I will share one funny story...once I had to give my cousin some money and I had gone to her house and I told her I am in a hurry to get to work so wait at the gate and I will give her the money.

She said "Akka when one is supposed to receive money from anyone..the person giving the money should come into the house and give the money...it is not good to give money outside of the house"

I was in a real hurry and I was getting impatient and I told her "When you go to withdraw money from ATM ....you are outside the house isn't it? Why that time you don't ask the ATM to come to your house??"

renukaji

Your argument seems to be very unreasonable; Money is equal to Goddess Sri Lakshmi and it is proper for the person to come in and give that to you!!
 
There are no superstitions; only beliefs.

Like one man's food is another man's poison, one man's belief is another's disbelief.

In one breath we say, faith can move mountains, but refuse to accept that someone else's faith can do him good or bad. Many beliefs are derived from scriptures, experiences, perception and intuition.

What is surprising that our exposure to a little bit of physical sciences and no exposure to spiritual and inner sciences, has made us critical of everything we do not understand. It does not stop with that; we want to eliminate and wipe out knowledge and practices which we do not approve.

Long live individual beliefs. <edited>
 
Last edited by a moderator:
renukaji

Your argument seems to be very unreasonable; Money is equal to Goddess Sri Lakshmi and it is proper for the person to come in and give that to you!!

Exactly, most people just drop off prasadam, gifts, money etc. at the doorstep. We should stay inside the house to exchange any thing and convey the wishes for the success of the venture. I like the practice of Karnataka/telugu people, who actually offer kumkum to the ladies while seated.
 
Once there is a scientific reasoning it is no longer a superstition. Many Hindu beliefs could be labeled as superstitions.

Normally the reasoning is very simple. When one does it, it is a belief. When some one else does it, it is superstition.

Where do we draw the line? Child sacrifices are horrible and should never be allowed to happen. But the basic belief behind the Child sacrifices does not change. Child Sacrifices have been replaced by Shaving one's head. But the principle is the same. When one breaks a Pumpkin in front of a shop with red kumkum, it is the same belief which is also behind Child sacrifice. When we say "Balim Baksha, Mama Kulam raksha" we are subscribing to the same belief.

How do we deal with such a situation. We have found a substitute for Child and other sacrifices, but continue with the basic belief of sacrifice.


Breaking coconuts/pumpkin etc. are done to cancel out the effects of 'Evil Eye'/Drishti. Dristi is really true, a happy couple or one with a child can be envied by a unhappy ones or barren woman.

As, the Supreme Person is believed to be present in every person, their thoughts can be fulfilled, if the other person is selfish or has karma. Karma regresses, so such acts to pray to the divine for one's welfare will cancel out the drishti.

This had been observed in many instances and hence has been prescribed by our shAstras. But, such acts are not required for true devotees, who live a simple, devote and compassionate life.
 
Superstition is a belief in supernatural causality: that one event leads to the cause of another without any physical process linking the two events, such as astrology, omens, witchcraft, etc., that contradicts natural science.

I agree that we may have some personal quirks, which may be termed superstition, but when our personal quirks are projected as something real to entire world then it is superstition, that should be curtailed. When our personal quirks effects others, that is wrong.

<edited>
 
Last edited by a moderator:
renukaji

Your argument seems to be very unreasonable; Money is equal to Goddess Sri Lakshmi and it is proper for the person to come in and give that to you!!

Dear PJ sir,

For me I really do not view money as Goddess Lakshmi..that is how all the problem starts when we equate money with Goddess and that makes us hanker for it more and more and desires get out of control.

Money is a piece of paper with value which is needed for mundane life and nothing more or nothing less.

I have lots of superstitious relatives who are highly educated but still have some believes that one should not give a safety pin to another!

Once me and my cousin were dressing up to go for a wedding and she needed a safety pin for her saree and I gave one to her and she told me to put in on the table and she will take it herself cos if one takes it from the hand of another ..the relationship might turn sour.

I find all these without any basis..all I can think is may be if a person give and pin to another it might accidentally pierce the other person and fight might start! so to prevent fights one is asked not to give it directly.

But frankly speaking who really wants to believe all these??
 
Last edited:

Old wine in a new bottle! I mean this topic.

I remember very well writing in our forum long back, about my belief of wearing a particular saree while travelling in a train!

Anyway Prasad Sir never misses a chance to attack! May be because he is the star of our forum, right?

........... I know one poster has been posting such 'gooble-de-gook' (thanks AMji for correct spelling) as learned postings in this site. Some others have termed it as researched writings. Let us step back and try to find logical reason and debunk all these useless 'gooble-de-gook'.

P.S: Some members start very many threads with links from TOI or copy pasting the OP from some other source! :cool:
 
Dear PJ sir,

Once me and my cousin were dressing up to go for a wedding and she needed a safety pin for her saree and I gave one to her and she told me to put in on the table and she will take it herself cos if one takes it from the hand of another ..the relationship might turn sour.

But frankly speaking who really wants to believe all these??

Now, I am trying to relate the two - pin/knife and money.

The former one shouldn't be given in hand, else who knows the giver may not have the right intention(revenge/anger) or may be careless. I heard one person got paralysed, when someone dropped a knife on his foot.

Whereas, money should be given on hand in front of witness!, so you are not framed ;) Plus, few wishes will remind the receiver of not abusing the money and using it for right purposes.
 
Last edited:

Dear Renu,

The pin or knife is not to be given in hand because it may hurt the one who receives, it if it is not handed over properly. But unless

threatened with some bad effect, who will listen? :lol:

'kaRivEppilai', raw mangoes, tamarind are all in the list of 'not to be handed over'! But, I can't figure out why? :noidea:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top