• Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

THE (UN)CLEAN CYCLE

GNANA SUNYAM

Active member
The menstrual cycle is nature's means of cleansing the women's physique.

What is the rationale behind demeaning it as unclean?

How does periods make a premise unclean?

One scripture of a foreign religion declares a woman as unclean during her periods and commands women to stay away from house for 7 days. She shall not enter a synagogue during cycle. Irony is it is being observed to this day.
 
The menstrual cycle is nature's means of cleansing the women's physique.

What is the rationale behind demeaning it as unclean?

How does periods make a premise unclean?

One scripture of a foreign religion declares a woman as unclean during her periods and commands women to stay away from house for 7 days. She shall not enter a synagogue during cycle. Irony is it is being observed to this day.
I am not sure it got 'demeaned'. But it was definitely considered from a practical sense without menstrual hygiene accessories that were available today. Hence Brhadharanyaka Upanishad recommends women in menstrual cycle don't drink from metal vessels for 3 days, does not allow husband and starts threshing rice only after 3 days (after taking bath).

As new times emerge with new tools and techniques, these are not needed. But people are slow to change their behavior that got ingrained in them. With social media Universities people come up with pseudo-science explanations and spread it. It's time whatsapp universities are broken.

Brhadharanyaka Upanishad compares menstruation to agni. Like agni prepares the clay to become pot, agni in invoked in stri to prepare her for procreation. Not just in mortal men and women, but also in the Yajna of Universe, where puruSa invokes the agni in Stri for manifest.

Can Agni be impure..? Never. Agni is the purest of all says the Upanishads.

 
Dear TBT

I like your well thought out posts whether I agree or disagree. Normally I don’t like to engage in topics coming out of an agenda but I posted here because I wanted to applaud you for your broad minded posts
 
MEN talking about women, and body shaming is reprehensible at best.

The stigma surrounding menstruation remains a significant challenge for women worldwide, with implications that stretch far beyond physical health. This stigma is not just about menstruation itself, but also about the broader cultural narratives that shape how it is perceived and discussed. Menstruation is often trivialized or even demonized, viewed as something inherently weakening or shameful. These perceptions can harm women’s mental and physical health, contributing to feelings of isolation, shame, and powerlessness.

The notion that menstruation is a taboo topic is one of the most damaging aspects of this stigma. For many young girls, there is little to no open discussion or education about menstruation before they experience it. This lack of communication fosters ignorance, perpetuates harmful myths, and inhibits the development of empathy and resilience. Girls often receive advice to remain silent about their periods, only discussing them with older female relatives in an attempt to shield them from potential embarrassment or ridicule from men. While this may seem protective, it ultimately perpetuates the silence and reinforces the shame associated with menstruation, leaving both girls and men ill-prepared to discuss the topic with maturity and understanding.

In many communities, menstruating women are socially ostracized, with some cultures insisting that they avoid routine activities, like household chores, to prevent "contaminating" others. This isolation can lead to a sense of powerlessness and diminishes the social standing of women. The cultural taboo against menstruation is so ingrained that it negatively impacts women's sense of self-worth and mental well-being.

Furthermore, the physical toll of menstruation is often dismissed. Many women experience pain, discomfort, and other health issues related to their periods, yet these are frequently overlooked or downplayed. The emotional and physical symptoms of menstruation are sometimes framed as irrational, contributing to the stereotype of women being unstable or overly emotional during their cycles.

In addition to these societal barriers, the lack of access to proper sanitary products and education, particularly in low-resource settings, exacerbates the situation. Period poverty, which refers to the financial, social, and political barriers preventing women from accessing menstrual products, is a significant problem. Without access to clean and safe menstrual hygiene products, many women and girls risk health complications, including reproductive tract infections. In some places, the absence of basic sanitary facilities means that girls miss school during their periods, which can amount to months of lost education every year. This perpetuates the cycle of gender inequality, as missed schooling reduces opportunities for girls to become self-reliant and delay marriage.

The silence around menstruation also inhibits efforts to implement effective public health initiatives. Without widespread education and open dialogue, misinformation and fear persist, further embedding the stigma. In many societies, these deep-seated cultural taboos, myths, and misconceptions around menstruation continue to contribute to the widespread belief that menstruating women are somehow "unclean" or less capable.

To break the cycle of stigma and its negative effects, comprehensive education and open conversations about menstruation are essential. Empowering women with knowledge about their bodies, menstrual health, and available resources is crucial. This will not only improve women’s physical health but will also foster greater social inclusion and equality. Educating both women and men is key to challenging harmful cultural narratives and building a more supportive, empathetic society where menstruation is regarded as a normal, natural process rather than a source of shame.

Menstruation should be encouraged to be recognized as key to being a healthy woman, and nothing to be ashamed of. It is certainly not a weakness, but a distinctive female characteristic that signals the ability to bring forth offspring. The need to conceal the blood may still exist out of consideration for the feelings of others, particularly younger people, who are often afraid of the sight of blood. Still, it should not be to hide the fact that one is menstruating.

Scientists and public figures should recognize and promote the fact that having a period is neither negative nor unnatural. The social construct responsible for such attitudes must be acknowledged and recognized to be the foundation for much oppression of women’s social status.

A celebration of what menstruation signifies physiologically—the continuing harmony of the brain and the ovaries to perpetuate the feminine hormone-driven reproductive physiology—would go a long way in casting out this negative construct and replacing it with one that values this deeply female experience, which is, in fact, essential to human reproduction.

 
If women’s reproduction and therefore menstruation serves society to perpetuate human existence, why do you think it would benefit society to have so much shame around menstruation?

If you want to oppress half the population, finding a visible way that half the population is different is a pretty good way to do it. ‘Oh, you bleed? That’s a sign of your physical inferiority.’ If we lived in a truly just society, menstrual products would be free, ultrasounds for issues related to the menstrual cycle would all be free, we would have universal childcare, we would have adequate maternity leave, and we’d have all these things because these things benefit society. This idea that you’re oppressing, or blaming, half the population doesn’t make any sense. But people or systems don’t stay in power because they make sense.
 
Every month, 1.8 billion people across the world menstruate. Millions of these girls, women, transgender men, and non-binary persons are unable to manage their menstrual cycle in a dignified or healthy way. In India, there are more than 35.5 crore menstruating women and girls, and many of them, especially those living in rural areas, face several challenges because of their menstruation, which restricts their autonomy and agency.

Menstrual hygiene remains a pressing issue in India, and a pervasive lack of awareness compounds it. For instance, research has indicated that anywhere between 29 percent and 71 percent of girls in India have no prior knowledge of menstruation before experiencing their first period. Cultural taboos and social stigma continue to negatively impact the menstruation experience. A national survey found that 70 percent of girls in India perceive menstruation as “dirty”, while over 30 percent experience fear and anxiety because of societal taboos associated with menstruation. Lastly, access to affordable and hygienic menstrual products remains a significant barrier. According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-4), only about 58 percent of women in India aged 15 to 24 use hygienic methods of menstrual protection. Many girls drop out of school and several others are excluded from participating in everyday spheres of life.

In India, there are various policies and schemes aimed at promoting accessibility to menstrual products and sanitation infrastructure. Among these are the National Menstrual Hygiene Scheme, Menstrual Hygiene Management Guidelines and the Swachh Bharat Mission.

However, more concerted efforts need to be made in educational and awareness-centred campaigns keeping regional complexities in mind. This is not only the responsibility of the Union and state governments, but also every one of us. So, this International Women’s Day, I call to action boys and girls, men and women to be agents of change and promote inclusion by ending period-related stigma and discrimination.

 
I feel women these days can decide for themselves what is "clean" or " unclean".

I remember as a teen my mother explaining when woman should not enter the prayer room etc.
Reason being is a woman is impure on some days and should not stand in front of God.

I remember the scolding I got when I asked my mum.." So God is ONLY inside the prayer room and He is not anywhere else?"

Anyway, its no big deal.
Humans have evolved in our perception of clean and unclean.
 

Latest ads

Back
Top