• Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Why we are not able to solve the pollution problem?

prasad1

Active member
Byrnihat, an industrial town in northeast India recorded a PM2.5 concentration of 128.2 last year – more than 25 times the WHO’s standard.

Twelve other cities in the top 20 are in India.

Its capital New Delhi featured as the world’s most polluted capital for the sixth consecutive year, with a PM2.5 concentration of 91.8. The report also listed six satellite cities – Faridabad, Loni, Delhi, Gurugram, Noida and Greater Noida – making the list.

Just last November, a throat-searing blanket of smog settled over Delhi, disrupting flights, blocking buildings from view and prompting the city’s chief minister to declare a “medical emergency.”

 
The main reason is simply colonialism. It sounds repeated, but that's the truth. Colonial rule has wiped out our country's main resources and, in fact, put us at a disadvantage (Bengal famine. partition, et cetera). In the post-colonial reality, colonial rule was replaced by capitalism, and owing to the disadvantaged position, countries within Asia were forced to take up factory work for the big corporations based in the West.

Maybe Trump's "Make America Great Again" campaign might help. (Most probably won't, but let's see)
 
Colonialism is not an answer for all of India's troubles.
India as a country did not exist before colonialism. We as Indians were never together before colonialism. Yes the Turks, Mongols, Mughals, and British ruled Indian subcontinent, and looted the riches of the land.

Overall, if we take a peek into the vast history of the rulers of India, we observe that India has witnessed the rule of several smaller kingdoms, while the power centers, mostly remained divided among the rulers of Magadha and Southern India. The bringing together of smaller states and kingdoms spanning from Himalayan region to Indian ocean, into one unified country was made possible only during the era of British rule.

India faces several challenges in addressing its pollution problems, despite significant efforts to tackle the issue. The reasons for this are multifaceted and involve a combination of socio-economic, political, and environmental factors:


  1. Rapid Urbanization and Industrial Growth: India is experiencing rapid urbanization and industrialization, especially in cities like Delhi, Mumbai, and Bangalore. With an increasing number of industries, vehicles, and construction projects, air and water pollution are inevitable. These activities often contribute to high levels of particulate matter, smog, and chemical pollutants.
  2. Population Growth: India has one of the largest and fastest-growing populations in the world. With over 1.4 billion people, the demand for energy, transportation, and resources is immense, leading to more pollution. The sheer volume of waste, emissions from vehicles, and industrial activities further exacerbate the problem.
  3. Dependence on Coal: India relies heavily on coal for its energy needs, particularly in power generation. Coal combustion is a major source of air pollution, releasing large amounts of particulate matter, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and carbon dioxide. The country is transitioning toward renewable energy, but this process takes time.
  4. Weak Enforcement of Environmental Laws: While India has environmental regulations, enforcement is often weak. Corruption, lack of political will, and inadequate infrastructure to monitor pollution levels contribute to poor implementation of laws. Many industries and vehicles are not held accountable for their emissions, and illegal dumping of waste is a widespread problem.
  5. Vehicle Emissions: The rapid increase in the number of vehicles, especially in urban centers, contributes significantly to air pollution. Many vehicles are old, poorly maintained, and emit large amounts of pollutants. While the government has introduced stricter emission standards (like Bharat Stage VI), the implementation remains inconsistent.
  6. Waste Management Issues: India faces a major challenge in managing the growing amount of solid waste generated by its cities. Inadequate waste segregation, limited recycling, and improper disposal of waste, especially plastic, lead to pollution of land, rivers, and oceans.
  7. Burning of Crop Residue: In some regions, particularly in states like Punjab and Haryana, farmers burn crop residue (stubble burning) to clear fields. This practice is a major contributor to air pollution, especially during the winter months, when wind patterns trap pollution in the atmosphere and create smog, which affects nearby cities like Delhi.
  8. Climate and Geography: India’s geographical location and climate contribute to the persistence of pollution. During winter, cooler temperatures and limited wind can trap pollutants in the atmosphere, especially in northern regions, leading to dense smog. The country's monsoon season also washes pollutants into rivers, leading to water contamination.
  9. Economic Priorities: Economic growth often takes precedence over environmental concerns. In many cases, the need to support industries and create jobs outweighs the necessity of implementing stringent environmental regulations. Additionally, pollution control technologies can be expensive and difficult to implement at scale, particularly in a developing country.
  10. Public Awareness and Behavior: While awareness of pollution is growing, behavioral change among the public is slow. People often engage in practices like burning plastic waste, excessive use of single-use plastics, and poor waste management. Changing entrenched habits requires education and incentives, which take time to establish.

Despite these challenges, India has made some progress in addressing pollution, such as implementing cleaner fuel standards, expanding renewable energy, promoting electric vehicles, and improving air quality monitoring. However, solving pollution problems will require long-term commitments, a balance between economic development and environmental sustainability, stricter enforcement of regulations, and greater public participation in environmental conservation efforts.
 
Last edited:
Colonialism is not an answer for all of India's troubles.
No one claims it to be. The reality is that colonialism as a phenomenon has been seen as a natural progression of society, and the intricate details of the damage it has done are hardly ever spoken of except for Independence Day. Even then, it is glossed over.

What colonialism and the subsequent blue blood overtake in politics has deepened the gap between the haves and have nots. This is not a caste issue but rather regarding the privilege given to certain members of the society during colonial times (education, wealth, et cetera).

Now, in India, you had two categories of people:
  1. The rich and Western-educated
  2. The majority of Indians who were seen as man-power
To keep the money flowing, many factories were set up by the former. These factories utilised the large labour force, which was also favourable for western conglomerates as they could now outsource production to "third-world countries" where the laws were in their favour. It is important to note that the factories also served as a source of income for the nation and did not stem solely from a capitalist-proletariat relationship.

How does all this relate to the environmental issue? As we all know, factories greatly contribute to pollution and, in fact, are the leading cause (for most Asian countries).

Therefore, colonialism is not an answer to India's troubles but has become the root cause of many of the socio-economic perils faced by the lay citizens. You may not like that colonialism has been brought up, but that is the reality we live in.

A quick Google search will show that points 5-7 are minor causes, and the major cause of pollution is the factories. Even with the techno-boom, India is still dependent on agriculture and production, with service being a smaller source of revenue. Global politics is key to the solution.

If you are interested in reading up more about understanding environmental lense through a third-world or developing nation's perspective, please go through the following:
  1. https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2...d-continues-to-exacerbate-the-climate-crisis/
  2. https://www.breeze-technologies.de/...developing-nations-than-in-developed-nations/
  3. https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/03/cop26-climate-colonialism-africa-norway-world-bank-oil-gas/
  4. https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202111/1237795.shtml
  5. https://www.fairplanet.org/story/how-climate-colonialism-affects-the-global-south/
  6. https://www.mdpi.com/2673-4834/2/1/8
  7. https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/story/air-pollution-hurts-poorest-most
 

Latest ads

Back
Top