• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Discipline Telangana BJP MLA who described Sania Mirza as Pakistan’s daughter-in-law

Status
Not open for further replies.

prasad1

Active member
In some circle it might be funny to poke fun at Muslim celebrities, but it is hurtful.
There is a latent hatred of Muslim community, as some Indian muslim are Pakistani supporters. But to paint all muslims as anti-India is gross injustice to the community.

A day after Indian tennis star Sania Mirza was appointed by the Telangana Rashtriya Samiti government as the new state’s brand ambassador, a local BJP leader’s description of her as “Pakistan’s daughter-in-law” is in bad taste. Leader of the BJP in the Telangana assembly K Laxman deserves a dressing down from the party’s central leadership for his reckless and insensitive comment.

Sania, who was born in Maharashtra but adopted Hyderabad as her home, is married to Pakistani cricketer Shoaib Malik. She has continued to represent India in tennis tournaments across the world. By questioning her nationality, Laxman has not just cast aspersions on Sania who enjoys tremendous popularity in India, but also sought to communalise the issue by claiming that by appointing Sania as Telangana’s brand ambassador the TRS wanted to appease minorities in the state.
As a representative of the BJP, Laxman has a problem which relates to his and his party’s limited worldview and a penchant for branding whoever does not toe the party’s line as anti-Indian. Laxman’s preposterous description of Sania is akin to claims in the past that challenged BJP’s veteran leader L K Advani’s nationality since he was born in Sindh in pre-Partition India.
Laxman’s comment is a reminder that the BJP still harbours a lunatic fringe which hitherto was being led by the Praveen Togadias, the Ashok Singhals and the Giriraj Singhs who have at various points in time espoused hatred for minorities and sought to divide people on the basis of religion. Laxman must realise, if at all he is capable of comprehending liberal values, that Sania is a popular brand name across India and her acceptance as an ace tennis player cuts across communities.
By Laxman’s skewed logic, even Saina Nehwal, who was born in Haryana’s Hissar district but subsequently settled in Hyderabad, is a non-local. And so are thousands of other software engineers who moved to Hyderabad from different parts of India and made it the country’s second cyber city after Bangalore.
Laxman and the likes of him represent the political Right’s anxiety towards communities other than their own. If the BJP is serious about Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s clarion call of Ek Bharat, Sreshth Bharat, it must discipline Laxman and others who harbour communal anxieties and give vent to such hostility.
Discipline Telangana BJP MLA who described Sania Mirza as Pakistan?s daughter-in-law | Times of India Blogs
 
Another incident in which the main issues of minority appeasement, injustice to andhra students, Muslim reservation increase and valid issues raised by bjp mla are pushed under the carpet. Anyway truth is slowly coming out, and laman will have the last laugh.
It is amazing that congress has clout over the media to spend days on irrelevant issues, when good work is deliberately ignored. Anyway one crore for sania's training in USA is a waste of public money. She is rich enough to fund hers.
There are instances of ordinary girls refused visas for marrying Pakistanis. Let us wait for developments.
 
TRUTH ALWAYS HURT those who do not want to practice it. incidentally you have only made an attempt to communilize this issue by singling out BJP MLA and not mentioning any word about Telungana Congress Party's reactions.
 
The earlier united Andhra Pradesh government had announced Rs 50 lakh each to Saina and Gagan Narang, both from Hyderabad, after they won bronze medals in badminton and shooting at the London Olympics in 2012.


They money, though, hasn't reached the stars even after two years. Following a report in TOI a few months back, the file regarding the payment had reached the secretariat. But elections and the bifurcation saga delayed the issue.

Sania has contributed to Indian success in this sport. the central and state governments foot the training bill for people who did not win anything any where. One crore for this level of achievement and worldwide recognition is on par with other athletes.

Some isolationist mama sitting in some corner of the world does not represent India. I think the jealousy and bigotry comes out clearly in the writings.

A person should be treated on the individual basis, rather than her/his spouse and any other choice they make. If Sania has given up her Indian Citizenship (I do not know) then I may agree that she should not get money from India. If she plays under Indian Flag respect her for being Indian.
 
Last edited:
After Big B’s big success as Gujarat’s ambassador, many states have wooed film stars. Telangana refreshingly chose Sania Mirza as its brand ambassador. She is undoubtedly one of India’s most accomplished sportswomen. After 11 year of professional tennis, she has just reached her highest ranking in women’s doubles — World No. 5. But all this counts for nothing with K Laxman. This BJP MLA from Telangana says Sania shouldn’t represent his state because she’s Pakistan’s daughter-in-law. This delusional charge has found fervent echo in other BJP members.
The problem with delusions is they wilfully neglect invalidating evidence. Sania’s popularity took no hit from her 2010 marriage to a Pakistani cricketer. Hyderabad celebrates her wins no less today than it did then. Fans across the country don’t think her Indianness has gotten mysteriously diluted. She continues to represent all of us internationally. Unfortunately, Sania has also gotten some practice in shuttling against the likes of Laxman. From a fatwa against short skirts to male chauvinism among sports administrators, she has had to face down a lot of tawdry attacks. All because the self-appointed moral police cussedly refuses to keep pace with actual public opinion.
Her mature response to the current controversy is that politicians should concentrate on solving more urgent problems. Is Narendra Modi listening? Unless he persuades his party folk to fall in line, they will keep stirring up the kind of poison his campaign put aside and his prime ministerial self shuns. The electoral cache of such rabble-rousing is measly these days. India’s notions of family are also evolving beyond the ‘beti hai paraya dhan’ mentality. On her marriage, Sania justifiably rejected some Pakistanis labelling her as trophy. She must find it equally horrifying to be labelled a Pakistani daughter-in-law now. These labels are deeply misogynistic. Sania is her own person.
Advantage Sania: Being a daughter-in-law doesn?t subsume a woman?s entire identity | Times of India Blogs
 
Did Sania fight for Telengana? Did she offer support to Telengana? She is now a daugher in law of Pakistan which has traditionally hounded Indians in general and Hindus in particular..So why should we go out of the way to support Sania? It is just minority appeasement!
 
hi

telengana wants show to support minority muslims in hyderabad.....its another political of TRS....
 
It is a typical short sighted not "well read" reaction by sections of media Sir. This issue of Sania is not a new issue cropped up after the new government, its a burning issue even between the two countries. The issue is not settled - the reason being citizenship law issue between the two countries. Pakistan don't allow dual citizenship and she is someone qualifying to be a citizen of pakistan under their laws. Here in India, the government give citizenship who are not born in India provided they meet certain conditions (like 7 year stay in India etc.). The minute that happen Shoab's Pakistanity nationality is stripped, hence Shoab don't even want to make occasional visit to India (rightly so). The UAE authorities allowed them living rights for this couple as a temporary gesture while the big question is still kept open. Even if she is a pakistani national, legally there won't be any bar to hire her as brand ambassador (for global reach, one may not want to hire VVS Laxman as cricket is played only in 8 countries whereas tennis has better reach !!). There is more to it than what is fed into drawing rooms by paid media....
 
Let us look at it in this way!

Sonia Gandhi who is an Italian by Birth & Citizenship married an Indian!

Thus Sonia became an Indian & became the head of the Grand Old party!

Will we accept her if she takes some responsibility given by Italy?

I don't think even Italians will agree!
 
Sania refused to hold the Indian Flag during Olympics? Why should we support her now?

BtUZHNfCcAA6Km9.png:large
 
Let us look at it in this way!

Sonia Gandhi who is an Italian by Birth & Citizenship married an Indian!

Thus Sonia became an Indian & became the head of the Grand Old party!

Will we accept her if she takes some responsibility given by Italy?

I don't think even Italians will agree!

Sir,
I know you are making a point and do not believe it. So I will let it stand.
You can voluntarily renounce the citizenship of the country of your birth, and qualify for the citizenship of other country.
No one gets citizenship just by marrying. This is not like "gothra".
We know our biases too, and some times in an anonymous platform we show it.
Please get your information right, just by mixing two names (that you hate), you are not making a point. That is like comparing apples to pineapple.

If you can prove that she has renounced her Indian citizenship you may have a point.
We also must remember that she travels to Pakistan, and has to take some precaution for her life, else there might be a fatwa.
 
There are other burning issues in Telangana like KCR's new rules for being recognized as a Tg domicile etc.

KCR is paving way for balkanization of India and no serious response from any party including BJP.

Instead they are harping on this non-issue about Sania being made brand ambassador and media taking the cue is lapping it up. Sania as a sportsperson was/is an inspirational figure to many young girls.

What a farce!
 
Sir, the issue too complex when it comes to citizenship. For every country, this is a sensitive issue including India. The Constituent Assembly discussed the issue at length while framing the constitution. Citizenship is not something easy which gets doled out (for any country for that matter). It consists mainly of three rights : Constitutional Rights, Statutory Rights and Political Rights. The rights of citizenship depends. Political rights is ultimate and this will get accorded only if such person fulfill all the conditions.. The intent of the participants were clear. The reason for Sonia Gandhi's famous renouncement too is outcome of constitutional provisions. She can acquire citizenship, she will also enjoy the constitutional and statutory rights - but not POLITICAL RIGHTS..
 
Sania Mirza married a Pakistani and therefore is Pakistan’s daughter-in-law, says Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) Telangana leader K Lakshman. But the same party refuses to accept Sonia Gandhi as an Indian even though she had married an Indian. Why?


Lakshman had one more gem—Sania was born in Maharashtra, so she is not even a local. Can’t be called Telangana brand ambassador. Granted.


How about Amitabh Bachchan who was born in Allahabad in Uttar Pradesh and entirely made his career in Mumbai, Maharashtra but was chosen to become brand ambassador of Gujarat? Why did the BJP over there not find any fault with Amitabh not being from Gujarat?


When Mehbooba Mufti amended property laws in Kashmir and said Kashmiri women married to non-Kashmiris won’t have property rights in Kashmir, there was a huge hue and cry. BJP wanted a national debate. They said Mehbooba was depriving Kashmiri women the choice to marry anyone they liked. Babu Bajrangi, a convict in Gujarat riots, for decades ran an organisation that would ‘rescue’ Hindu girls who were ‘lured’ by Muslim boys and were led away from Hinduism. Bajrangi and his ilk from the Sanghparivaar termed it as a wide conspiracy by the Muslims and it was called as 'Love Jihaad'.


BJP and the sanghparivaar won’t admit it now, but for our saffron brigade Hindu and Indian were synonymous. It’s for other religious minorities that they must wear their patriotism on their sleeves. It’s the same mentality that has been displayed by K Lakshman. If at all, it’s in line with what the Sanghparivaar has always belived. It’s in line with what VD Savarkar wrote in his book 'Six Glorious Epochs of Indian History', where he cries over Hindu women being taken over by aggressor nations.
What?s the difference between Sania and Sonia? | Latest News & Updates at Daily News & Analysis
 
Did Sania fight for Telengana? Did she offer support to Telengana? She is now a daugher in law of Pakistan which has traditionally hounded Indians in general and Hindus in particular..So why should we go out of the way to support Sania? It is just minority appeasement!

Okay, lets call it a truce and label Shoaib as the son in law of India.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top