N
Nara
Guest
Folks, unity is a good thing, unity gives strength, courage, camaraderie, etc. etc. These give power to the united group. But power is not an end in itself. How and for what purpose this power will be used need to be carefully considered. Unity is desirable only so long as the resulting power is used in a compassionate manner to promote the well being of all our brothers and sisters.
In this context, what is the purpose for this appeal for Hindu unity, and that too urgently, in this very hour?
From the discussions I have seen so far the main objective of this unity seems to be to stand against the unrelenting push for conversions coming from the west. If I am right in this assessment, then we should see (i) whether this threat of conversion is real and if so what is the magnitude of the threat, and (ii) is unity the answer for this threat.
Firstly, if you look at the census statistics of India you will notice that the percentages of Christians have remained more or less stable. So, the threat of mass conversion is largely a bogey man.
Secondly, prevention of the conversions that do take place does not require all Hindus to unite, which is a daunting task to say the least. There are two other simpler and more achievable things all of us can do instead.
From what I have observed, the reasons for preventable conversions are mainly social and some economical. The government provides a range of economic incentives such as reservations and subsidies to those who are vulnerable to convert. Let us support these programs, they will make the economic inducement less effective.
The second thing all of us can do to prevent conversion is to address the social reasons. Many of the potential converts do take the plunge out of despair that they are treated badly and not allowed into temples. I am sure putting a stop to these practices will take the second powerful reason to convert.
On the other hand, this call for unity may have nothing to do with conversion, it may just be a way to build a political movement to take India back from the oft derided pseudo-secularists. If this is the agenda, then I think Hindus are better off staying away from such attempts. Promoting a religion based political ideology is a dangerous thing.
On a different plane, is unity among Hindus even possible? Hindu society is divided and sub-divided into thousands of castes. With each caste, and even sub-caste, viewing caste solidarity as the be all and end all of life, how is this unity going to come about. Any such attempt is doomed to fail and ironically each caste will blame the other castes for the failure. Dr. Ambedkar dealt with this issue in detail, which I summarized here.
True unity is impossible among Hindus unless it gets rid of the caste system.
peace ...
In this context, what is the purpose for this appeal for Hindu unity, and that too urgently, in this very hour?
From the discussions I have seen so far the main objective of this unity seems to be to stand against the unrelenting push for conversions coming from the west. If I am right in this assessment, then we should see (i) whether this threat of conversion is real and if so what is the magnitude of the threat, and (ii) is unity the answer for this threat.
Firstly, if you look at the census statistics of India you will notice that the percentages of Christians have remained more or less stable. So, the threat of mass conversion is largely a bogey man.
Secondly, prevention of the conversions that do take place does not require all Hindus to unite, which is a daunting task to say the least. There are two other simpler and more achievable things all of us can do instead.
From what I have observed, the reasons for preventable conversions are mainly social and some economical. The government provides a range of economic incentives such as reservations and subsidies to those who are vulnerable to convert. Let us support these programs, they will make the economic inducement less effective.
The second thing all of us can do to prevent conversion is to address the social reasons. Many of the potential converts do take the plunge out of despair that they are treated badly and not allowed into temples. I am sure putting a stop to these practices will take the second powerful reason to convert.
On the other hand, this call for unity may have nothing to do with conversion, it may just be a way to build a political movement to take India back from the oft derided pseudo-secularists. If this is the agenda, then I think Hindus are better off staying away from such attempts. Promoting a religion based political ideology is a dangerous thing.
On a different plane, is unity among Hindus even possible? Hindu society is divided and sub-divided into thousands of castes. With each caste, and even sub-caste, viewing caste solidarity as the be all and end all of life, how is this unity going to come about. Any such attempt is doomed to fail and ironically each caste will blame the other castes for the failure. Dr. Ambedkar dealt with this issue in detail, which I summarized here.
True unity is impossible among Hindus unless it gets rid of the caste system.
peace ...