• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

'I was battered, bruised and blackmailed'

Status
Not open for further replies.

prasad1

Active member
The_Hindustan_Times
The Hindustan Times - Indian Newspapers in English Language from three editions


I am a British citizen married into an affluent Delhi family. My husband is a practising psychiatrist at a Delhi hospital. My father-in-law is professor emeritus in psychiatry - he has worked at Safdarjung hospital and PGI Chandigarh and has been the dean of top medical institutes. I am a licensed physician in London for the past 15 years and worked as a general practitioner there. On the face of it, I am married into an educated, well-to-do family. I am a proud professional myself, a practising doctor, but I have been battered and bruised. My marriage has fallen apart. Behind my shattered life lies the deep-seated, Indian male mentality that considers women a mere commodity. A mindset that seems to be prevalent across India, be it an educated household or an illiterate family in a nondescript village.


Beginning of torture
After the marriage, my husband came to the UK to stay with me and look for a job. I supported him with money and housing for one year. And all that I got in return were constant dowry demands and physical, mental and emotional torture. My husband used to tell me that he would divorce me once he gets a job there. I was told he had every right to have sex with me as I was his property by virtue of marriage - something he claimed his father had told him. He was taught that he had the licence to use and abuse me as he wanted.


He filmed sexual acts
He would film sexual acts with me and later blackmailed me by threatening to upload the contents on the net. He even said he would send the recordings to my parents. The abuse reached such a stage that once I had to call the London Metropolitan Police. But I dropped the charges against him later as I wanted to give him a chance. My husband's family wanted me to spend my annual earnings of 90,000 pounds on them and invest it in their property business. My husband couldn't get a job in the UK and returned to India when he felt I was not relenting. From India, he pressured me to join him in Delhi and threatened to file for a divorce if I refused. I relented to save my marriage. I gave up my flat in London, and relocated to Delhi to give my marriage another chance.


Pressure for divorce
But there was no end to my travails. The entire family ganged up against me and told me to sign the divorce petition as my husband wanted to marry again for more dowry. I was under tremendous pressure but did not relent.
I am a spiritual person but my in-laws' attitude was a shocker. They would throw my books and my deities, stop me from going to the temple or offer prayers in the house.
They would stay up late in the night watching indecent stuff and crack indecent jokes. I have no mother-in-law and my sisters-in-law live elsewhere. So, it was only men in the house - father-in-law, husband, brother-in-law and a male servant. It was like a boys' hostel.
They would put my luggage in the servant quarters. When that failed, they tried to electrocute me by leaving live geyser wires on the wet floor of the bathroom. I became pregnant but the abuse turned worse - I was often kicked and punched. And they were all qualified psychiatrists.
Despite this endless torture, I had decided that no one could force me to agree for the divorce or do something until I wanted to do so. I spoke to my sister-in-law, who was also abused in this family. She told me to lie low but it didn't work for me.


Pregnancy didn't change anything
Six weeks into my pregnancy, I left for the UK to earn and save for to-be-born child. My husband assured me that he would call me in the seventh month and take proper care. But when I came back in the eighth month of my pregnancy, things were back to square one.
My husband dropped me at my parents' place in Agra for the delivery as he didn't want to pay a single penny.
After the birth of the baby, neither my husband nor anybody from his family kept in touch and snapped ties with me.
I approached the Delhi Commission for Women (DCW) following which my father-in-law rung up and threatened to implicate me in a theft case. When I went to my husband's house to get my belongings, my brother-in-law stopped me, saying I didn't belong there. I waited for two hours in the scorching heat of May with my seven-month-old baby and then called the police.


Hostile police
But the police refused to file an FIR (though registered a complaint). They told me that I cannot enter the house as I did not live there. They said forced entry would be a non-cognizable offence and so they can't help me. I was shocked. A man can be sent to jail even for a verbal abuse in England but in India, they did not even consider denial of entry to a woman's matrimonial home as a crime. My brother-in-law told me that approaching the DCW and registering a complaint of abuse was my biggest mistake and that I must pay. I returned to my parents in Agra and filed a domestic violence suit against my in-laws which is pending hearing. I just hope that my in-laws are made to pay for their misdeeds.


Divorce is no solution
Women's safety is a big concern - both inside and outside homes. Men like my father-in-law and my husband are dual personalities - outside, they are bright minds and brilliant professionals; inside, they have a typically narrow mindset and think of women as commodities meant to be used and thrown away. They feel a woman's place is only in the kitchen and in bed. I feel that divorce is not a solution in such cases. The laws must be stringent enough to change the mindset of men towards the fairer sex. Divorce is only a ticket for such people to go scot-free, looking for another prey. Only effective and women-friendly laws can make them think twice before treating the institution of marriage as a business arrangement.
 
I just don't know what to say except, abuse sees no caste, creed, education or gender.. it is prevalent among Indians and in other part of the world.. I am sorry this lady who is a trained physician did not leave her husband even before she became pregnant.. and she should have stayed in London and should have complained to the police there, when she was tortured..

I can fully understand also that why she was reluctant to do so.. her own family and pride of having an intact marriage was more important to her, but when her safety was threatened why did she not do it.. It is not easy to live with abuse.. it is so sad, that women lose themselves completely in this and start believing in all the lies they are told about themselves and do not feel they are worth living in this world..

I do feel for her and hopefully she would get a divorce and just move on.. there is a better future for her and others who are victims in this society..
 
bush,

i think the lady concerned, is of a different mettle altogether.

as she has clearly stated, giving a divorce, is giving the husband a licence to repeat his game all over again. there are enough gullible folks in this world, who would see him as a victim, and rush to give their daughters and feel the pain later.

by keeping him dangling within the thread of holy matrimony, she has got him by the ba**s.

notwithstanding, that hindustan times may be duped into publishing this story (it is over a year or more, and i have read it before), as one never knows, in this age of sensational journalism, this is a good 'what if' situation story, to warn our daughters.

i dont know how my children's lives would turn out, but as a rule, i would point blank, advice them against marrying boys/girls just from mid east or north india - ie the boy/girl are immigrants with parents and immediate familly in the old country - only reason - if there is an issue, these go back to their countries, taking the children with them, and one never hears or sees these children afterwards.

quite some years ago, there was a heart wrenching story of a north indian woman, whose husband went to jordan, without warning, taking the kids with him. when she went to jordan to look for her family, the first question posed to her was if she was a muslim!

such is the standards there, and there is no reason, why our children should be scapegoats in the alter of political correctness. to protect our own, let us call 'a spade a spade'.
 
the institution of marriage as a business arrangement.

hi
the reality of modern world.....its price of so called modern life....byproduct and consequences of material world....no emotional/

human values here....money is the criteria and comforts are the motive...real happiness are gone...no cultaral/humanity here...

many more sad stories yet to come....im not supporting olden days life,,,,,still some kinds of attachement to the family

and children....my grandfather had 13 children...my father was eldest son...my grandfather was ONLY BREAD EARNER...

my grand mother was uneducate and illetrate house wife...husband and kids are ONLY HER WORLD....I THINK STILL SHE

WAS CONTENDED AND HAPPY HOUSE WIFE....WE ARE 36 GRAND KIDS FOR THEM...... i have 36 cousins still there....
 
dear tbs,

i am not so sure with your statement re your mother or grandma. p

lease do not take this personally, as i am not writing this with reference to your family, but more in general, to women of those era.

personally, i think, with distant time, and with what they presented to us, as grand children, we feel that our grandma had great lives. almost all of them had no opportunity, if at all. maximum allowed was sslc, or most of them, eslc, if at all that.

music learning was encouraged, but only to the point of proficiency to impress the prospective in laws, who, most often after marriage, dissuaded them from singing/performing to anyone, but immediate marriage. i know a child prodigy, who after her marriage in 1959, was shut inside the kitchen and was not even shown the veena (went upstairs to the paran, never to be retrieved still).

and we all know what happened to our widows, even upto the late 1960s...

my own immediate family, a cousin, 10 years younger than me, a danseuse, was shunted off to the kitchen, housework, and literally to take care of the fil needs. and cursed for her bharatanatyam expertise, as if it was a whorish past time. this happened in 1980s, when the world became more enlightened.

atleast, my grandmother, used to rue the fact, that she was not even allowed to wear the modern sari, which became fashionable since 1930s. my own mother, fretted at being to the house, when she had so much spare time, and wished to teach or volunteer - either activity - frowned upon by my dad, because he felt, it was below his dignity, for the community to see his wife doing such stuff.

all in all, the girls of today, particularly from our community, have it almost as good, though not quite, as our boys, in terms of opportunities respect and expectations of the parents. that it works many a times, detrimentally, to boys looking for wives, especially from families with attitudes of bygone days, is not an excuse, to patronize those times, as 'good old days'. there never was such. the present is any day better for vast majority of folks. atleast, i think so.
 
Ok let me start out by saying, this is definitely a tragic case and I dont doubt any aspect of it.

But there are certain things about the lady's psychology that I dont understand. She makes it seem that she was just a passive victim. Why? At least in the UK she could have called the police and thrown the man out?

If sex acts were filmed, why did she agree? Why did she not protest and refuse to participate. If he did beat her, why not tell others? Nobody just becomes pregnant. If it was a loveless marriage, why did she participate in physical relations.

Somehow I just cant digest that an educated women these days will take all this lying down. Certainly I havent met such a person. That's the best defense: be vociferous and protest.
 

I agree with the views of Biswa Sir. How can an educated lady with such a good job and income commit such silly mistakes?

How can a lady allow the intimate acts being video-graphed? Did she want the baby of that non-loving and abusing husband?

Did she ever think of the future of that baby? I am confused!! Divorce is not a stigma now-a-days. She should have reported to

police in London and terminated this useless relationship.

P.S: Why is this posted in chit chat and not in G D by Prasad Sir?
 
when young folks are in love and make love, they do all sorts of things. whether it be posing nude or taking films, one cannot fathom the reasons. not all the time, rationale prevails.

after all this is your husband whom you love, and whom you think loves you. there are no borders within love. only giving.

in this context, i can fully understand the protogonist's actions - whether it be permitting the husband to take blue films of her or her decision to leave a lucrative practice in london and go to delhi.

sanity speaking, i would have considered going to delhi is similar to stepping to a viper's den. especially knowing the odds are stacked against you - i am quite sure, the in laws behaviour must have already manifested in many a nasty acts.

prudency would have been to stay behind in london and move on in another path. humanity and feeling for her husband, and a desire to make best of a bad situation, made her come to delhi. having given him a long rope to hang himself, he is just doing that. a very courageous and strong willed lady.
 
I have sympathy for the lady.
We are involved in an organisation here in USA which helps women in abusinve relations, in PIO community.
Even in the present day, a lot of Indian families are more interested in how they are judged by others, mostly family and friends back in India. The ladies and more the girls family are willing to accept so much of abuse that our american lawyers are amazed.
We too advice all options, including Divorce, the girls and sometimes the parents of the girl are reluctant to accept that divorce is better than ending up dead.

A family friend of my wife, living in India was abusive and claimed that we were the problem in the marriage of his daughter. We had rescued this girl from Hospital, because her husband beat her and abondoned her in a different state. She had no money and being on H4 had no chance of earning any money. We arranged for her to stay in a safe house, but the girls father was upset that we did not try hard enough to locate the boy and restore the marriage.

So please judge this incident from Indian perspective.
 
....

So please judge this incident from Indian perspective.

it has been my experience 'indian perspective' - is one of name calling against supposedly western values, supposed superiority of asian values and above all coming up with blame syndrome, without ever trying to methodically and dispassionately look at the root cause.

i have found, that certain unpleasant things rather must not be talked or discussed or even brought forward verbally. i have also witnessed from supposedly modern and intelligent people, holding highpositions outside of india in multinationals, blatantly sexist and racist, when it comes to indian values, wifery, property division and ranking for respect.

what i see is the inconsistencies that we appear comfortably cloak ourselves with, all in the name of tradition, culture or plain greed. i am unable to distinguish many a times ...
 
Living in abuse is not something new friends, it can happen to any sane woman, what happens is you become indifferent, thinking the next day would be better, O if I have a child it would be better, and in this lady's case, perhaps she did not know that she was being recorded and I have heard in some marriages they like to watch and perhaps it was something just between them in the beginning.. she might have thought so, innocently... just because she lived in london does not mean anything...

A victim literally freezes when she is repeatedly told the same thing and she has no way to escape until such time she gathers courage somehow .. it is not easy to live like that, I do admire that girl for putting up such garbage for so many years.. some ladies, I know have put up with some physical and mostly utter horrific hurting mental abuse for more than 25 years of their marriage..

As Prasad said there are some organizations in the US aimed at helping South Asians I have heard many stories how badly young recently married man abuses his wife because he is stressed at work.. I know someone who has turned into a total alcoholic and has young children, the wife is unable to make him stop.. she is still with him.. I have advised him many times, but he goes back to it like clockwork..

With all the organizations and the help you know you might get, family honor comes to mind and what if the husband harms her and her child comes to mind so it is not all that easy to get away from it all.. it is not easy.. Nobody deserves to be mistreated..

Talking about olden days, it was not unusual for someone to abuse their wives.. My own relative's mom used to be beaten and verbally abused.. after my second daughter's marriage, she committed suicide by pouring gasoline on herself and it was the most shocking thing I had heard when I was barely ten.. I will never forget the sadness I felt..

In another case this man used to beat his wife up so badly and after sometime, he would go and apologize to her and care for her wounds, but this woman had no place to go or it was not the norm to complain to her family, of course what else her husband's pride will suffer.. I know so many who have suffered..

So when some of you question why a woman puts up, she does because of many many reasons.. at least I hope the future generation sees each other as equals and work towards having a good marriage..
 
Its very easy to ask why didn't she do this or do that or not do this and that as someone looking on from the outside. If only we all had the benefit/wisdom of retrospection beforehand...we can't predict ourselves what we'd do if we were in her position tbh.
 
Its very easy to ask why didn't she do this or do that or not do this and that as someone looking on from the outside. If only we all had the benefit/wisdom of retrospection beforehand...we can't predict ourselves what we'd do if we were in her position tbh.

My post was not to dwell on what she should have done, I agree with you and more over it is already done deal. We all can learn from her situation and help others who are in similar situation. We do that, but the attitudes differ on the basis of culture. I have not lived in India for more than 40 years, I can see that the difference in my approach, from those who are coming from India.

Some people indulge in finding a solution to History, I am trying to fins a solution for the future.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top