• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

India Is Building New Toilets Every Second—but Hardly Anyone Is Using Them

Status
Not open for further replies.

prasad1

Active member
Faced with what you could plausibly call the world’s biggest pile of crap—the feces left behind every day by the 600 million people in India who defecate outdoors—the recently installed government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi has launched a campaign to build 5.3 million latrines by the end of August. That’s one per second. Trouble is, countless Indians still prefer to poop in the fields and on riverbanks, like they always have.


As Bloomberg’s Kartikay Mehrotra reports, many rural folks find the idea of defecating where they live disgusting. “Feces don’t belong under the same roof as where we eat and sleep,” one woman tells Mehrotra, explaining why she and pretty much everyone else in her village do their business in a field, despite her new government-installed toilet. “Locking us inside these booths with our own filth? I will never see how that is clean.”


Open defecation is a colossal public health problem in many countries, but it's especially acute in India, where as much as half the population lacks access to toilets. Excrement contaminates drinking water, spreading diseases such as diarrhea, which kills some 600,000 Indians every year—many of them children. Girls and women are also assaulted on their way to distant fields; in May, two girls heading home after defecating outside were raped and hanged from a mango tree.


Nonetheless, a survey of rural households by the Research Institute for Compassionate Economics finds that most people who own government-provided toilets don't use them. The key issue, the researchers say, isn’t supply; it’s demand. Indians need to be much better educated about why they should be using latrines.


The good news is that great progress is being made on this problem. In the last 20 years, the percentage of people defecating outdoors worldwide has dropped from 24 percent to 14 percent. Want to know more? We took a close look at the issue in our recent series "Insanitation."
India Is Building New Toilets Every Second?but Hardly Anyone Is Using Them
 
I have noted that people in India have toilet phobia.

When I was a student in India..a friend of mine stayed in a house where she rented a room from a local family.

I used to go there on and off to visit my friend.

Once I noted the house was stinking cos the toilets were not cleaned for 2 weeks cos the cleaner lady was ill and had not come.

I asked my friend why isnt the house owner cleaning the toilet herself/himself till the cleaner lady arrives..the stench is unbearable.

My friend who also belonged to the same community as her house owner said that in India only certain communities are supposed to clean toilets and others do not do that work..so we cant clean the toilets cos a toilet is dirty.

So the problem here seems some stigma attached that a toilet means its dirty and people rather have a dirty toilet instead of cleaning it themselves.

I guess the same mindset applies here too..that a toilet is dirty and who is going to clean it?

No one wants to clean even their own house toilets in India..I have noted even middle class families in India have cleaners who come to the house to clean the toilet..something I can not understand why?

What is so hard to clean your own toilet?

We surely know rules of hygiene better than any regular untrained cleaner I am sure.

I think the Indian mind has lots of unsettled stigmas of the ancient kind.

Even my recent trip to India made me conclude the Change is something unknown to some parts of India at least.

A visit even to some Religious book stores in Bangalore would make you wonder why when the books you are buying comes with a bar code and a computer is right in front yet they prefer to hand write each book name and price down on a receipt...make you wait till they are done.
Then calculate each with a calculator and then some other person also sees to it again and then someother person packs the book and then you pay.

With a scanner..one just needs to scan the bar code and the price would appear(if it has been coded) and one just needs to print the receipt and pay right away.You only need 1 person for this ..but here 3 people were needed...one to write and calculate..another to re do it and another to pack the books.

Its waste of time and human effort.

One ashram in Blore also is even worse..after writing everything by hand and after 2 people check it then another person keys everything into the computer!

Why cant it be scanned into the computer right away and save everyone's time?

No idea!

But dont try suggesting ever anything to anyone..it never works.
 
Last edited:
My friend who also belonged to the same community as her house owner said that in India only certain communities are supposed to clean toilets and others do not do that work..so we cant clean the toilets cos a toilet is dirty.

So the problem here seems some stigma attached that a toilet means its dirty and people rather have a dirty toilet instead of cleaning it themselves.

I guess the same mindset applies here too..that a toilet is dirty and who is going to clean it?

No one wants to clean even their own house toilets in India..I have noted even middle class families in India have cleaners who come to the house to clean the toilet..something I can not understand why?

Doctor Madam,

There used to be a thotti who used to do the toilet cleaning some 30 years back..Nowadays we clean our toilets..Most of the are western and it is not a big deal to clean toilets..Just add a drop of Harpic chemical and use the brush to smear it and then flush it with water..It is very effective
 
Dear Renu,

You are talking about a 'long ago' story! Now, we can't even utter the name of that caste which used to clean toilets.

Those days are gone. All the mAmis and sometimes mAmAs only clean the toilets in their houses. It is a daily routine

before having a bath. Even if the servant maid agrees to scrub and clean the bathroom floor, she will NEVER clean the

toilet in the same room. That is the position now a days.

Reg. the book store stories: May be the shop keeper wants to give jobs to more persons! And........ the bar code reader

should be attached to a computer, if one person manages the billing. Many shops don't invest in that kind of machine.

In a few provisional stores in our area, they have bar code billing; in all other shops, they write on a one side paper and

add the amount. :)
 
People do not clean hands after attending the nature's call and many guys consider any compound wall as their urinals.

My son used to call them 'jagan nAththans' / 'ulaga nAththans' / 'viswa nAththans' - those who nAththify the world! :yuck:

In Kolkata, there was a place for men to do #1, but there was no sight of water near by! In public toilets, many don't use

water and hence the stink in the toilets will make us vomit! Only now, I find some 'AyAs' near the toilets in airports, who

check and clean the toilet, if needed, after each lady's visit!

P.S: I developed a habit of washing my hands with soap, if I use a pen given by any courier guy!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top