• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Is dictatorship better than democracy???

Status
Not open for further replies.

prasad1

Active member
Most researchers write about dictatorships from an outsider’s perspective.


“[Many of them] assume the reason injustices persist in dictatorships is the same reason injustices persist in democracies,” he says, but that’s not the case.


“When you live in dictatorships, everyday common people who may even be illiterate are very aware that they’re living in a corrupt system,” he says. “They’re not fooled by ideologies. What keeps them in their place is the gun to the head … brute force.

”Adolf Hitler:
In 1930, Germany was still a young country (barely 50 years old), and its people didn't have a sense of German "identity" yet. Adolf Hitler was a brilliant speaker and a strong organizer. He used all this German disenfranchisement to his advantage. He motivated the people, developed a sense of German pride, and convinced them that they deserved better. Eventually, Hitler convinced the Germans to go to war again, and World War II was underway. In a sense, Hitler brainwashed a nation.


The unprovoked invasion of neighboring countries and the murder of over six million innocent people aside, Hitler's war effort is credited with causing several scientific advances and the creation of products we still use today (the Volkswagen, rocket engines, and jet propulsion are three examples). Hitler also built a much needed infrastructure in Germany, including dams, railroads, and the world's first national highway system (the Autobahn). I suppose you could say these are positive contributions to the world.


But I think Adolf Hitler's most important contribution to the world is this: He showed us what unchecked greed, unabashed bigotry, and loathing and hatred for humankind can do. Hitler has given us an example of the worst kind of person, and the worst thing that can happen to humanity.
We all know about Hitler's reputation. But did he do anything good? Why did the Germans listen to him if he was so awful?
 
Hitler brought the sense of pride to Germans. At times it went overboard to fuel superiority complex though.

But similar sense of pride was brought by Vivekananda too. Only, Vivekananda did not keep the gun on anyone's head.

In a controlled, guided situation dictatorship can be good.

When people are corrupted, democracy doesn't work efficiently. India is an example.

In general, people are not really connected to governments. Such situations may not succeed well.
 
As an example it is the norm to talk about Hitler, "The Great Dictator".

However what if we talk about Lee Kuan Yew, the founder of Singapore, or let's say Akbar or Deng XiaoPing. A benevolent dictatorship can make quick progress, but it is relatively rare.
 
Democracy only works when the constituents involved are well informed , passionate about results, and willing to serve for larger cause.
Since this is a rarity the democracy as an institution rarely succeeds.

Let us look at this news item

The less Americans know about Ukraine?s location, the more they want U.S. to intervene

Tough speaking jackasses tend to be least informed.
When some American people were asked where Ukraine was in a survey after they had taken a strong position about US intervention they place Ukraine all over the world :-)

Someone placed it in the island of Madagascar!

Dictatorship by a few smart people may be far better than democracy by bunch of nincompoops LOL


 
in 1976 ,emergency was imposed on india and we had a dictators rule for 19 months.lots were thrown in jail. press censorship was clamped. initially good things happened . govt offices worked in time . railway stations were cleaned and trains ran in time. people got good access to public distribution system. even singles got ration cards.there was more courtesy in public dealings. then it went wrong badly . people got forcibly sterilised to fulfill quotas. homes were demolished under slum clearance and people left on roads far away in peak winter.houses were demolished while clearing roads for good movement of people. Rumour mills got active preading canards about misdeeds of govt. people suffered due to high handedness of govt. when emergency was lifted, the govt was thrown out with a vengeance. there is nothing called good dictatorship
singapore has been converted into a state with no freedom with state having firm control over every aspect of citizens life. the price they have paid for prosperity and good life is enormous.
 
Last edited:
If I am the dictator than its Ok!

I will rule like Yama Dharmaraj but at the same time recreation would be like Indra Loka.
 
But similar sense of pride was brought by Vivekananda too. Only, Vivekananda did not keep the gun on anyone's head.

Well said.

I fully agree..I had noted that when I read works of Swami..I guess at that time he wanted to instill national pride among Indians but if you ask me I feel the feeling of Pride for even a good reason eventually turns to Prejudice.

So its always better to instill Love..cos Love can be shared and its all encompassing but Pride is a limited feeling..when cant share Pride we can only feel it in our self and it has not good outcome finally and what is there to feel so proud about anything actually? as if we made this world and are fully in control of anything.

Love on the other hand can cross all borders known to mankind.
 
hi

the answer is YES....sometimes democracy becomes DEMO CRAZY.....all parties are crazy in their actions...there is beautuful

song in malayalam.....PODHU JANANGALE KAZHUTHAKKALIYA MADHU PAANA CHAKRAVATHI IVAN ALLE..means some times

the drunken chakravarthi makes the common man into donkey.....
 
I am one big fan of Hitler, Putin and the so called dictators. Dictators have the natural ability to lead, to decide and to empower.And that is why they come to power. Germans were wandering tribes and they had no exceptional history . Do you think they had a history of being so efficient, straightforward and hard working ? Those feelings were nurtured only through revolution and great leaders like Hitler and Bismarck.

US is a successful democracy, but it was born out of revolution and war. Democracy all over the world and Democracy in India is different. We didn't even rewrite our laws and we simply followed the British. And what did British do? They basically divided people. India boasts of vibrant democracy but our fate lies in the hands of some backward states such as Bihar, Bengal and UP who make up the majority of the decision making process.

Atleast initially you need to establish an order in the society, then you can talk of freedom and other shit..As others pointed out, democracy is useless if people are un-orderly.


I always have a strong belief that " A terrorist kills you once but a greedy leader kills you everyday throughout your life" .
 
Reply to Mr. Assault.

Dictators may be good at leading people, but if they are paranoid dictators they lead them to their doom. Note how Hitler led Germany to a crushing defeat and then committed suicide like a coward. Similarly Stalin committed genocide.

I had mentioned benevolent dictatorship. I was thinking, would I be a benevolent dictator myself? I think the problem is the loss of the feedback loop. Sooner or later, the dictator becomes divorced from reality.
 
I had been off the forum for a long time because of a few hatches, patches and despatches which include our last pc. I am sure none would have missed me as the world is too crowded and here I am if I can make it thicker.

In political system, Democracy is the right one which is subject to questioning and moderation. Probably we had democracy in the beginning after independence but soon sycophants replaced democrats. Let the world cry out against IG emergency, but that was the best period - Indiaraji's rule - we have had so far. The opponents have all been self-centrists. During her regime the world started noticing India. What has spoiled present India is the multi-party system of democracy in which the constituents (of cousins, friends and enemies) show only a lower order of character from one another, who may not have just seen the whole map of India. Nevertheless, the democracy is best suited every where provided we can give the country a responsible administration and judiciary.
 
It is like entropy; left to itself, the entropy or chaos will increase to infinity.Intervention is necessary to bring order and reduce entropy.

Our system is not rile by majority, but by manipulating minority. Perhaps we have to find a system to ensure majority is represented (one should not jump to the conclusion - hindu muslim) by having a two step voting with top two candidates go for a second election and a new election if nota is in the majority.

There is even a high court judgment that reservation cannot exceed 50% as the minority status is automatically nulled.
 
If not dictatorship , we want king like ruling just like in the middle east so that progress will be uninterrupted if we have a correct kshatriya ruler

r.vaithei
 
are you referring to renuka ji as ghost or ghost as reincarnated as renuka ji
kindly take it in the lighter vein:bump:
r.vaithehi
 
are you referring to renuka ji as ghost or ghost as reincarnated as renuka ji
kindly take it in the lighter vein:bump:
r.vaithehi

Dear Vaithehi,

I am the Paranormal Expert!LOL

Seen also sorts of Ghosts including the Kadhal Pisase!
 
i thought you are a normal person..now you are saying para normal..that means you accept my comment whole heartedly..expert..means...pampin kaal pampu ariyum..that's why you are able to identify kadal pisasu....:clock:r.vaithehi
 
i thought you are a normal person..now you are saying para normal..that means you accept my comment whole heartedly..expert..means...pampin kaal pampu ariyum..that's why you are able to identify kadal pisasu....:clock:r.vaithehi


What is the meaning of Pampin Kaal Pampu Ariyum? I am not that much an expert in Tamil...kindly translate.
 
It is always better to have a strong leader and a long term rule rather than have corrupt and weak and coalition governments
r.vaithehi
 
pambu means snake (don't think i'm calling you snake)..it is said that only snake knows snake legs..like that a criminal will be able to identify a criminal...a pisasu can only identify a pisasu (MAY BE I'm ALSO PISASU...:target:r.vaithehi
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top