We all suffer this identity crisis. A TB in Delhi or Mumbai also has to go through this process, only the distance is farther.I am unable to make out what indians in america want.they suffer from an identity crisis.
after reading all the posts , I am unable to make out what indians in america want.
they suffer from an identity crisis.
either they should be americans adopting the way of life there and become comfortable or they should retain their
indian values ,stay aloof and return to india after a few years of work.
riding two horses is never a good idea.for the generation which has gone to US from india they have this
predicament.
for the generation , born and brought up there , it is unwise to thrust anything indian on them.
they can get easily get assimilated there. in any case,no one is going to miss them in india. so why bother them ?
they are many people of indian origin settled in south america or west indies. they hardly think of returning to
india.only the US indians appear mixed up considering periodically the indian option. It only complicates their life
Renukaji,
I am amazed at your capacity to quote such songs at the drop of a hat. You are very resourceful with that. I would say a sabbaash and enjoy the scene that pans out before me in my imagination:
A Doctor's consulting room. Doctor is Renukaji.
Enters a patient with severe stomach pain.
Doctor asks him to go and lie down on the patient's couch for examination. The patient obeys.
Doctor gets up from her chair and starts dancing and singing "randakka randakka randakka randakka whoa whoa whoa" and approaches the couch. The patient is dumb struck. His pain has gone away.
The doctor continues
Chalo Chalo Ji Lak Lak Gao Lo
Chalo Chalo Ji Mauj Bana Lo
Chalo Chalo Ji Nach Lo Gao Lo
Pakad Kisi Ki Wrist
And We Twist
We Twist
We Twist
We Twist
And We Twist
We Twist
We Twist
whoa whoa whoa.
The patient gets up and thanks the doctor, pays up and leave dancing and mumbling "randakka randakka randakka". LOL.
No offence meant. Just laugh it away if you can. I hope you won't send Tyson after me.
As far your next generation born and brought up in US is concerned,, the indian past of their parents as such is noDear Krish ji,
What is the condition in which 'Identity Crisis' will appear? Only when someone has not an identity with a formal set of values. So on contrary to your accusation, I perceive only those children born to Hindu parents here who do not attend such schools as potentially having identity crisis when they grow up.
Besides, living in the West does not mean one has to compromise their own unique set of inherited values and embrace Christianity or Western ways, for that also has its own set of problems.
Even the Irish here teach their girls 'tap dancing' paying hefty $$ and observe Irish festivals such as 'St. Patrick's Day' and send children to Sunday schools. Same with Muslims, Jews, African Americans and the rest.
In my observation, children should know where they hail from and this presents them with a true and clearer picture of who they are - so in case of Indian/Hindu children, that they are Hindus hailing from the lineage of immigrants to USA. This only adds interest to the variety in usa, does not act against the spirit of usa!
Cheers,
As far your next generation born and brought up in US is concerned,, the indian past of their parents as such is no
relevance to them . It is just a baggage they have to carry of the past. it is just information to be stored with little
or no utility for living in US, when they transact with other americans, they will be as equal american citizens with
same american way of bringing up. it is simple to be accepted as an american with values of freedom ,democracy
and equal rights believing in capitalism and free enterprise . why complicate it by thrustng indianness on them.?
I think the children will eventually get there, Krish ji. Honestly as parents, we are all bewildered by the diverse set of people and principles our children are exposed to. Our goal, as a Hindu Indian American, is not to make 'another Indian' out of teaching kids Indian values, but quite the contrary, to instill in them a sense of healthy pride over what 'they inherited' from their parents and their way of living - which might guide them to make certain wise choices and most importantly, to recognize and avoid making inappropriate choices. But, to tell you the truth, no one knows how life will turn out to be inspite of all our attempts in teaching any set of values to children. They may assimilate about 25% of our values, and then their offsprings might know none. So when I see it from that angle, it is only a losing game, of losing one's identity as a Hindu and an Indian as generations spring forth. But this is where I believe individual destiny and karma comes into play. Who knows, my grandchild may be a White American Christian, but may be otherwise super well-off! And my children may not feel they lack anything out of this configuration. Anything can happen, but as I said, it is purely to impart children a set of values and a system of worship popularly known as 'religion', only this is within the reach of what we can contribute to the children in helping them make wiser decisions and only time and their own individual destiny decides who they are.
1. There are people who had their young formative years in India as part of a Hindu family and yet has learnt absolute nothing about their traditions, culture value system etc., These are unfortunate individuals who had monsters of a parent who failed miserably in their duties to their children. These individuals (let us speak about only brahmins here) would have left their poonools in the coat hanger at home or better worn it whenever they needed a tool to scratch their back (Kamalahasan et al). They would declare it too proudly with a false sense of pakuththarivu bravado among their friends. Such people will give "unconditional love" as an opiate to their children too and let them live a licentious life in the western society and would also claim that "living one's life" is an individual's choice. I consider such people as hopelessly lost. Their karma load is such that they have wallow in whatever darkness they are in. There is no use trying to argue with such people or reason it out with them. They are supremely confident that they are right and we are wrong. Sin is always sweet and enticing. These people(brahmins) will lose their indianness and brahminness completely in course of time and will just end up in the melting pot of civilizations,cultures and values called the US as a tiny mashed morsel. I write them off and have no time for them.
But in my family, my husband is totally against going back and settling in India, for reasons he alone can justify. And besides my son is 19 yrs old now and having spent his entire lifetime growing up in a different culture, he won't accept to go to India. As for me, my honeymoon with America is over long since and I am in a mood to rather go 'kshetratanam' to different pilgrimage spots in India and would love to live there. So it is hard for me to start a school, etc for NRI children. But I will keep in mind the rest of the pointers you gave.
The sadness part is quite genuine - leaving out my family, I believe every Indian/asian family who are living in the West have to face at some point in their future generations' choices, that their culture gets merged with the predominant Western culture. If not in 2nd generation, maybe in 3rd or 4th or 5th generation. Returning back to India is the only choice.
Best regards,
JRji,
I have been out of India for the last 45 years. We visit India every 2 years, and have visited most of India except for the NE. I have investigated living in India. I have come to a different conclusion. Then again I am not a romantic, I am a realist.
I am retired from my profession, but have various business interest in USA. My child is older and in good job here, I would rather stay close to her. Both of us are the youngest in our family, and some of our relatives are in USA. India as a tourist destination is ideal for us. If you really try to live on your own (family), with out the help of local people who make it happen for you on your visit, you too will find out that you do not fit in the present society of India. The things that you yearn for are not the same on present time. It is not like the "good old days", then again it never was.
I have friends who "returned to India" come back to USA. Unless you return to India in your younger days to good job then it might be dream come true, otherwise it is just empty feelings.
I have had friends who sent their children to India for schooling and cultural protection incur the wrath of these children for making their life miserable.
Instead of riding two boats moving in opposite direction at the same time, make the jump and stick with it. Keep your options, life may throw a surprise, be prepared for it.
I don't know about others, but for me, inspite of a million other Indians living and working here, I always feel 'Indian' in any situation - at a workplace, and while at my son's or daughter's school situation talking to other parents, while socializing with Americans. I think this feeling is just a 'me' thing... I always feel alien here. I feel alien to the culture too irrespective of having spent the prime of my life for 20 yrs now. I do not watch American shows, they feel little 'too odd' for me/culturally way-off, except for some comedies, some Hollywood info and news. But the sad part is whenever I visit India, I feel equally alien there too. The TV shows and soaps, the common people all don't seem 'genuine' to me for some reason... So I think I am a total misfit, I neither belong here nor I belong there... I am happy my husband and children have their own 'home' atleast... otherwise it is scary! LOL.
prasadjiJRji,
I have been out of India for the last 45 years. We visit India every 2 years, and have visited most of India except for the NE. I have investigated living in India. I have come to a different conclusion. Then again I am not a romantic, I am a realist.
I am retired from my profession, but have various business interest in USA. My child is older and in good job here, I would rather stay close to her. Both of us are the youngest in our family, and some of our relatives are in USA. India as a tourist destination is ideal for us. If you really try to live on your own (family), with out the help of local people who make it happen for you on your visit, you too will find out that you do not fit in the present society of India. The things that you yearn for are not the same on present time. It is not like the "good old days", then again it never was.
I have friends who "returned to India" come back to USA. Unless you return to India in your younger days to good job then it might be dream come true, otherwise it is just empty feelings.
I have had friends who sent their children to India for schooling and cultural protection incur the wrath of these children for making their life miserable.
Instead of riding two boats moving in opposite direction at the same time, make the jump and stick with it. Keep your options, life may throw a surprise, be prepared for it.
prasadji
your post appears most realistic and pragmatic.
one cannot put the clock back and hope to see india one left behind 45 years back.
life and times change
one has to have the pragmatism to accept change and not live in dreams of the past . worser still to foist that old indian way of living , thinking and traditions on the
next generation born and brought up in america. they will never forgive what you do to them. the damage caused thus is irrepairable
parents think they have some special duty to inculcate some special indian values in their children.
children subjected to such cruelty abroad are going to hate their parents for a lifetime for what they are trying to do to them.
Dear JR,
Why do you say you neither belong here nor there?
May be becos you constantly compare yourself with the surrounding and when you find a difference you start to feel out of place.
When I visit India I do not feel out of place becos I know my purpose there is for a visit and to have fun and not to start feeling familiar or get personal with anyone or anything.
Yes..its different from back home here but the difference does not make me out of place but it is just a new experience.
If we look at everything as a new experience we will never feel out of place.
.......if we try to hard to restore the glorious past of any kind..that shows that the person feels he has no future.........
hiHere where we live (MA, USA) there are nice private non-profit organizations such as 'Shishu Bharathi' that cater to the needs of parents wanting to teach children Indian values and languages. Currently Shishu Bharathi offers its services in 3 places within MA and there are total of 1000 - 1200 children. In other states such as NJ, I heard that equivalent organizations such as 'Bala Vihar' offer their services, but whether they are as successful as SB, I don't know.
SB offers the following services:
1. Teaching of languages - Tamil, Kannada, Hindi, Marathi, Telugu, maybe a few more.
2. Teaching of Indian culture - I should perhaps say 'Hindu culture' - SB teaches children about various festivals, freedom fighters, panchatantra tales, national flag, national anthem and such.
3. Grades KG to 8 addressed.
4. Gandhi Jayanthi, Jawaharlal Nehru's birthday, Independence Day, Republic Day are observed.
5. Teachers operate on a non-paid voluntary basis. However, this is a great opportunity to build-up the resume to aim for teaching profession at schools.
6. Indian Day and some other functions like this are observed every year when all 3 individual schools unite and spend the day with cultural programs and activities.
7. Children are trained in drama, and dance programs to participate in other outside activities such as to participate in 'New England Tamil Sangam' (NETS) for Pongal festival, etc.
8. Great opportunity for parents to get to know and interact with other Indian parents.
Besides the above, even the local temples offer cultural activities. For example, at the Ashland Sri Lakshmi Temple, there is 'Stotra class' for youngsters every Friday.
So, I should say, the children have a routine that very much reminds being in India.
They say, "the more the merrier", it is so true when coming to having lots of our folks together in one place. Such activities and organizations become a possibility!
Cheers,
Jayashree