sangom
0
Dear Shri Nara and friends,
I have given my opinion on AH crusade. Let us now imagine that the GOI completely buckles under the AH wave and passes a JLP Act exactly as drafted by the Anna Team and everything is in place. To my limited knowledge and experience, law enforcement has always been kept separate from the judiciary. But the AnnaLokPal (ALP) will have CBI under its control and can also pronounce its judgements on corrupt officials; is this a salutary thing? Or, is my understanding of the ALP draft wrong?
2. With the ALP in place and working in full swing, can anyone of us say honestly that we will not have the temptation to use "influence" (like our close relative-father, son, brother, sister or in-laws) in some position of discretionary authority and we want something done by "jumping the queue", from a railway sleeper ticket to anything beyond? Will this not be the seed of the gigantic tree called corruption now? How many of us will be able to completely control such temptation? That is why I firmly believe that India is not yet fit for a corruption-free phase.
I know from experience that brahmins are no less (and probably no more) susceptible to using such "influence" - where there is no cash given as bribe - and get goods and services out of turn. This was very prevalent in the olden days of perennial shortages but even today, when almost everything is abundantly available, including imported stuff, I can count a number of brahmin households who take great pride in boasting that they brought it (Plasma large screen TV, ultra-modern fridge, washing machine, a/c etc.) in without having to pay customs duty because "so and so had influence, so-and-so knew the customs people, etc."
So, let us be honest to ourselves that corruption is ingrained in us despite whatever high philosophy and all we may discuss here.
I have given my opinion on AH crusade. Let us now imagine that the GOI completely buckles under the AH wave and passes a JLP Act exactly as drafted by the Anna Team and everything is in place. To my limited knowledge and experience, law enforcement has always been kept separate from the judiciary. But the AnnaLokPal (ALP) will have CBI under its control and can also pronounce its judgements on corrupt officials; is this a salutary thing? Or, is my understanding of the ALP draft wrong?
2. With the ALP in place and working in full swing, can anyone of us say honestly that we will not have the temptation to use "influence" (like our close relative-father, son, brother, sister or in-laws) in some position of discretionary authority and we want something done by "jumping the queue", from a railway sleeper ticket to anything beyond? Will this not be the seed of the gigantic tree called corruption now? How many of us will be able to completely control such temptation? That is why I firmly believe that India is not yet fit for a corruption-free phase.
I know from experience that brahmins are no less (and probably no more) susceptible to using such "influence" - where there is no cash given as bribe - and get goods and services out of turn. This was very prevalent in the olden days of perennial shortages but even today, when almost everything is abundantly available, including imported stuff, I can count a number of brahmin households who take great pride in boasting that they brought it (Plasma large screen TV, ultra-modern fridge, washing machine, a/c etc.) in without having to pay customs duty because "so and so had influence, so-and-so knew the customs people, etc."
So, let us be honest to ourselves that corruption is ingrained in us despite whatever high philosophy and all we may discuss here.