Renuka JI –
On the contrary, you don’t seem to get the point !!
First off, you love to go out of the topic – It is not about “whether I think money is everything”. I am not the topic here… By the way, I am talking about milkman’s son needing money for sustenance. So, how that translates to “money is everything for me” beats me…
All of us know first comes greed, then ethics, then corruption, & white collar crimes… but that is NOT the topic of discussion here.
Again I am asking you – “what will be your advise to the milkman’s son, not to your son who is privileged to have you & your husband to support him with all the necessities” Again the topic is – for all normal poor people like milkman’s son.. not about you or me…
So everyone needs “money for basic survival to pay the bills” – this is a “must” & “not optional”. Again let me repeat, I am not talking about millions, billions, trillions, greed, ethics, values etc... I am talking about “normal poor people” like the milkman's son who needs say 15,000 INR per month… for sustenance..
Having said all this…
1. Lets focus “only on the statement” without worrying about the “impact” – “Marks are everything in life”
2. Money for "sustenance" comes from a Job, Job comes from having a college degree, college degree comes from “minimum pass marks”. So "marks are everything in life".
3. For a milkman’s son, the “only way out is education, marks, degree, job” otherwise his survival is at stake. Millions have descended into poverty, crime due to “lack of diploma/college degrees”
4. Lets please keep Steve Jobs, great entrepreneurs, heroes, etc.. “out of the picture” LOL !!
5. So answer to statement in #1 is “unequivocal yes” (Again don’t worry about the suicide impact – I will come to this)
6. So “without worrying about the impact”, the answer is“yes”
Great, now we have “focused only on the statement” & got the “answer” cleared, lets focus on the impact.
Lets analyze the impact:
1. Road accidents are common, so do we stop going out ?
2. Airplanes, Cars, etc.. all meet with accidents,so do we stop driving them ?
3. Jobs are stressful, many have suffered health problems, some have died, some have suicided, so do we stop working ?. do we tell our kids – it is okay if you don’t have a job… somehow “money will fall from the trees to pay the bills” ?
4. College is stressful so do we tell people to stop going to college ?
5. Life itself is stressful & full of risks, do we go to God & say – stop the entire creation ?
So now because a “few students suicide due to the enormous pressure on them by parents, etc.” does NOT make the “statement –marks are everything in life untrue” like “job stress leading to suicide ” does not make the “statement – Jobs are absolute must in life untrue”
Hopefully this clarifies… LOL !!
Cheers,