Indian muslims should emerge out of Khilafat mindset

[கால பைரவன்]

Share:

Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Share Link

Redirect Notice

 

[Jaykay767]

Indian Muslims have to do this, do that etc.

Similarly, now can you ask your favourite party leaders to stop - spewing hatred against Muslims, stop building detention centres - eerily spine chilling similarity with nazis, etc. ??

And can you ask them to - reverse CAA, proposed NRC, reach out to Muslims, and build a inclusive society ??

 

[கால பைரவன்]

Indian Muslims have to do this, do that etc.

Similarly, now can you ask your favourite party leaders to stop - spewing hatred against Muslims, stop building detention centres - eerily spine chilling similarity with nazis, etc. ??

And can you ask them to - reverse CAA, proposed NRC, reach out to Muslims, and build a inclusive society ??

What a load of crap. There are no detention centers. They are not behaving like Nazis etc. Why should CAA be reversed? Should not the persecuted minorities in islamic countries be given preference over the very people who are persecuting them?

It is astonishing really. You people want 370 to be abrogated - because you don't want other indian citizens to get settled in Kashmir but you oppose CAA because you want muslims from other countries to have a free pass to India?

Why do you pretend that you are a liberal? Why don't you openly say that you want Sharia to be installed everywhere in India?

 

[Jaykay767]

Can you care to respond to these news articles ?

India is building a mass detention center for illegal immigrants, less than a month after it effectively stripped 1.9 million people of their citizenship

Last month, the government put out a final list of all the residents in Assam considered to be Indian called the National Register of Citizens (NRC).

www.businessinsider.com

 

[Jaykay767]

India’s massive, scary new detention camps, explained

The Indian government stripped citizenship from 2 million people, mostly Muslims. Now it wants to put them in camps.

www.vox.com

 

[Jaykay767]

What a load of crap. There are no detention centers. They are not behaving like Nazis etc. Why should CAA be reversed? Should not the persecuted minorities in islamic countries be given preference over the very people who are persecuting them?

It is astonishing really. You people want 370 to be abrogated - because you don't want other indian citizens to get settled in Kashmir but you oppose CAA because you want muslims from other countries to have a free pass to India?

Why do you pretend that you are a liberal? Why don't you openly say that you want Sharia to be installed everywhere in India?

No we simply cannot as per constitution. You can write a bill saying- all persecuted people will be given citizenship including Muslims !! You cannot exclude Muslims or any religious groups.

 

[Jaykay767]

First of all, just because, we oppose CAA and NRC does not mean, we want sharia law. Let's not go to extremes.

Abolishing article 370 without consent of the state govt and its people is unconstitutional. Let's first get this correct. Hence this has to be reversed. No one is against anyone settling in Kashmir.

 

[Jaykay767]

Post the rise of right wing govts across the world, the great thing is that liberalism, inclusiveness and equality to all, has taken on a tidal wave !! Nothing to do with minority appeasement, vote bank, politics, etc...

 

[கால பைரவன்]

No we simply cannot as per constitution. You can write a bill saying- all persecuted people will be given citizenship including Muslims !! You cannot exclude Muslims or any religious groups.

First of all the constitution guarantees rights that are applicable only to Indian Citizens . Even so there is no ban on muslims or any other religion group. The CAA is just a means to fast track citizen ship of persecuted religious minorities. A muslim or any other religious person from any other foreign country can still apply for indian citizen ship. There is no bar for any muslim from a foreign country to become a citizen. Such processes have always existed and the CAA does not change that.

 

[கால பைரவன்]

First of all, just because, we oppose CAA and NRC does not mean, we want sharia law. Let's not go to extremes.

Abolishing article 370 without consent of the state govt and its people is unconstitutional. Let's first get this correct. Hence this has to be reversed. No one is against anyone settling in Kashmir.

You are allowed to make a reference to Nazism but a reference to Sharia is extreme? Sorry. The fiberals' behavior is much more akin to jihadis than hindutva to Nazis. When you drop the extreme language i will drop it too.

Kashmir is an integral part of India. And article 370 affected all people of india not just those from Kashmir. It was appropriate that the decision to abrogate that was made by a democratically elected govt of India.

 

[Jaykay767]

You are allowed to make a reference to Nazism but a reference to Sharia is extreme? Sorry. The fiberals' behavior is much more akin to jihadis than hindutva to Nazis. When you drop the extreme language i will drop it too.

Kashmir is an integral part of India. And article 370 affected all people of india not just those from Kashmir. It was appropriate that the decision to abrogate that was made by a democratically elected govt of India.

Well, If you are not seeing yet, the entire international media both liberal and conservative is going hammer and tong about the nazi comparison. If this detention centre thing had come to light before the Loksabha elections, the results would have been different. So much for paid media hiding and obfuscating such critical information.

In a federal democracy, the centre cannot take unilateral action without consent and approval of state legislature.

 

[கால பைரவன்]

Well, If you are not seeing yet, the entire international media both liberal and conservative is going hammer and tong about the nazi comparison. If this detention centre thing had come to light before the Loksabha elections, the results would have been different. So much for paid media hiding and obfuscating such critical information.

In a federal democracy, the centre cannot take unilateral action without consent and approval of state legislature.

Do you want us to believe that the so called international media has the interest of indian people in mind? Such astonishing naivete on your part.

And you are still in denial w.r.to the last LS elections. You always question legitimacy of elections EVM hack etc which proves you refuse to accept reality. Abrogation of article 370, CAA, were all part of BJP manifesto - so one can say people voted FOR them.

The obfuscation is from the fiberals because that is the only way they can capture power. Not the other way around.

 

[Jaykay767]

Do you want us to believe that the so called international media has the interest of indian people in mind? Such astonishing naivete on your part.

And you are still in denial w.r.to the last LS elections. You always question legitimacy of elections EVM hack etc which proves you refuse to accept reality. Abrogation of article 370, CAA, were all part of BJP manifesto - so one can say people voted FOR them.

The obfuscation is from the fiberals because that is the only way they can capture power. Not the other way around.

Please do not claim moral high ground on this. Only this govt is super national and rest are anti national, anti india etc..let's not go there.

This govt and its institutions conducted themselves unfairly, blatantly, and silenced the media and gave little to no coverage to the oppositon and the liberal secular view points in their desperate attempt to grab power again. They conducted propaganda against the oppositon as anti national, urban naxal, etc. And we are yet to get to the point of potential evm rigging..so there is nothing to gloat over the election win.

Just because it is in the manifesto, and people voted for it, does not make it right. Religious discrimination is totally unacceptable in today's day and age. So there will be rightly indignation and oppositon to such ideas.

Oh please, let's not get into this, everyone has an agenda, paid by liberals, sickular etc..and is against this super govt. it may be hard for supporters to understand that many people are genuinely concerned about human rights in Kashmir, and elsewhere in india and the world.

 

[Jaykay767]

First off, please do the right thing, don't worry about liberals, sickulars with an agenda ..international media, etc..

1. If you consider Kashmiris as Indians then restore normalcy to Kashmir. Restore Internet services, allow free media access.

2. If you are not against Muslims, then include all the refugee / immigrant Muslims in the CAA bill like we did for the Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, etc..

3. Demolish the detention centres or give it to some charity organisations. How on earth and that too in gods name, can we even talk about detention centre forget building one, after the horrific holocaust that marred the last century ??

Astonishing, lack of moral judgement for a party that claims to be rooted in the hinduism of vasudaiva kutumbakam.

4. Reach out to Muslims and build bridges instead of blaming them for everything.

Statesman are born from extraordinary leadership that ack. mistakes and course corrections,not by digging heels into the ground and fighting a immoral war !!

 

[கால பைரவன்]

3. Demolish the detention centres or give it to some charity organisations. How on earth and that too in gods name, can we even talk about detention centre forget building one, after the horrific holocaust that marred the last century ??

What is astonishing is that the fiberals never talked about detention centers all these years.

The detention centers were first set up to tackle the problem of infiltration along the Bangla border by the then "Congress" government. These were created in 2012. Refer to the white paper document released by the then Congress govt on this issue.

This was very specific to problems faced by Assam. The detention centers are at Goalpara, Kokrajhar and Silchar.

 

[Jaykay767]

What is astonishing is that the fiberals never talked about detention centers all these years.

The detention centers were first set up to tackle the problem of infiltration along the Bangla border by the then "Congress" government. These were created in 2012. Refer to the white paper document released by the then Congress govt on this issue.

This was very specific to problems faced by Assam. The detention centers are at Goalpara, Kokrajhar and Silchar.

If true, then it totally wrong on congress part. One of the reason I penned way back, that opposition parties have to build their party cadres based on liberal inclusive ideology.

But again, one has to look at the context. If a openly anti Muslim party says, we will build detention centres and then pass a bill where all refugee communities will be accepted except Muslims, then only Muslims will reside in detention centres ??

And then you want to blame international community and liberal seculars for drawing parallels with Nazi regime ?