dear forum senior members
thanks for the quick clarification. my hubby is interested in isha yoga and doing this regularly. he says onion & garlic *& brinjal are negative pranas. they r banned in isha centre. so we shd also try not to eat. ok we will follow yr advice as it is acceptable by youngsters. thank u.
uma bala
Sow. Uma,
With due respect to your husband and his devotion to some kind of yoga practice (I have not heard about this isha yoga before, but just now googled and found it to be Jaggi Vasudev's - am I right?), let me tell you that avoiding the use of onion or garlic is just a superstition, and a fashionable one at that. The Sanskrit word for onion is palANDu and it is referred to in Mahabharata, Susruta Samhita, some of the purANas, etc. Modern research says that it is useful for fighting against osteoporosis, (
Onion - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia), a condition more common particularly in females.
Jains have great food fads and that religion prohibits eating of anything which is taken from below the ground. Hence orthodox Jains don't eat any tuber and also onion, garlic, etc. (But I have seen some otherwise orthodox jains eating roasted ground nuts.) Brahmins started giving up meat-eating, took to vegetarianism and also adopted some of the food restrictions from other groups like the jains in an effort of one-upmanship, when the brahmins had to regain their social supriority, when the Buddhist and Jain religion were being beaten back. The onion-garlic taboo came in during this phase of hinduism.
Ayurveda which classifies substances based on their purported gunas and onion and garlic have been supposed to induce sexual drive. But this is a questionable claim because the brahmins - in most parts of India - who did not use these items were as prolific as the dalit or non-brahmin who ate these items.
Nowadays the modern day gurus and swamis almost invariably lay down onion-garlic taboo, wearing of 'madisar'/panchakaccham by women and men when doing pooja, at least, fasting on certain days etc., etc., just to impress their devotees.
Hence I would suggest that you consult a doctor or nutrician on the demerits/merits of this taboo. discuss with your husbans and try to convince him that it does not have any of the demerits for which it is avoided. Of course some people get excessive flatulence and so avoid this; similar trouble is experienced by some others when they take some other items like tur dal. If the taboo is on account of such reasons, well, it is OK.
You may satisfy