Hello,
(Note: this might feel like a rant but I have some genuine questions at the end of my narrative)
I was brought up as a brahmin and moved to the US for undergrad. My parents were orthodox (not too extreme) but go to the Temple every day, and do pooja every day in the morning, I was thought Vedas during middle school. They still cooked onion at home for me but not garlic and ate outside in restaurants as well.
One thing I never understood was why Brahmins had so many self-imposed restrictions like cannot eat meat, cannot marry/date people from another religion, etc.
I have friends from the US who follow all sorts of religions and none of them were excluded from their community or became less Jewish, Buddhist, etc, just because they didn't follow certain conventions. Their parent didn't mind what their kids ate or whom they dated, they themselves weren't excluded from the community, etc.
My friends usually ask me why I am not dating anyone and don't eat meat. My usual answer is this is how I was bought up and my parent would feel unhappy. I am extremely religious, since I was bought up a certain way some of my parent's principles like telling slokas/ verses from Vedas in the morning, etc. stuck by me and I still continue to do it even in the US.
During my undergrad in the US, I had a conversation with my parents where I asked them if it was ok if I date someone who was Japanese. I haven't even told her I like her yet, my parents told me that I cannot and if I do, they won't be able to show their face in the community or take part in activities in the temple. At this point, I lost it. I wasn't angered but just disappointed. They told me I have to marry a Brahmin girl, I can date a Brahmin girl if I find one or it is going to arranged marriage with a Brahmin girl.
It has been 5 years since then, I haven't found any Brahmin girl whom I was attracted to nor did I end up dating anyone else who I was attracted to because they weren't Brahmins. At this point, all my friends have a girlfriend, who mostly aren't even of the same religion. I told my parents I am not interested in an arranged marriage because I cannot marry someone that I don't genuinely love and I cannot love someone without spending at least a year dating them and getting to know them. I asked them again if it was OK to date someone I like but my parents again gave the same answer from before.
At this point, I started losing faith in the community as a whole. I know my parents are good people and they love me. I also know that I am a good son, I never asked for any expensive stuff when I was young, I had decent grades, got a very good scholarship in the US for my undergrad, and have a high-paying job. I send money to them every month and cleared off all their loans.
But now I have a genuine question, does your kids' happiness mean so much less to you than to your pride in the community? Why is the Brahmin community as a whole quick to outcast someone because they didn't marry into the community (I genuinely believe this because I have witnessed this when I was a kid)? I am not questioning every individual who are Brahmin but trying to understand what goes on in some people's mind when they outcast someone in the 21st century for marrying because their kid married someone they loved? I don't really care if I am an outcast but my parents do.
At what point should I say enough is enough and decide that I will marry whom I love and not someone whom my parents believe is a good match. Because although I might be their kid, there is a lot in my life they don't know about. I am close to losing faith, throwing in the towel, and even consuming non-veg which I thought I never would because I genuinely don't understand all these restrictions in this modern age when people from other communities (not all) have so much freedom.
I am probably going to end up not marrying anyone in my life if my parents are opposed to me dating from outside the caste or religion. I was to open in my love life and marry who I want, if that's not possible I might as well end up a bachelor all my life. Let's see what option my parents choose.
(Note: this might feel like a rant but I have some genuine questions at the end of my narrative)
I was brought up as a brahmin and moved to the US for undergrad. My parents were orthodox (not too extreme) but go to the Temple every day, and do pooja every day in the morning, I was thought Vedas during middle school. They still cooked onion at home for me but not garlic and ate outside in restaurants as well.
One thing I never understood was why Brahmins had so many self-imposed restrictions like cannot eat meat, cannot marry/date people from another religion, etc.
I have friends from the US who follow all sorts of religions and none of them were excluded from their community or became less Jewish, Buddhist, etc, just because they didn't follow certain conventions. Their parent didn't mind what their kids ate or whom they dated, they themselves weren't excluded from the community, etc.
My friends usually ask me why I am not dating anyone and don't eat meat. My usual answer is this is how I was bought up and my parent would feel unhappy. I am extremely religious, since I was bought up a certain way some of my parent's principles like telling slokas/ verses from Vedas in the morning, etc. stuck by me and I still continue to do it even in the US.
During my undergrad in the US, I had a conversation with my parents where I asked them if it was ok if I date someone who was Japanese. I haven't even told her I like her yet, my parents told me that I cannot and if I do, they won't be able to show their face in the community or take part in activities in the temple. At this point, I lost it. I wasn't angered but just disappointed. They told me I have to marry a Brahmin girl, I can date a Brahmin girl if I find one or it is going to arranged marriage with a Brahmin girl.
It has been 5 years since then, I haven't found any Brahmin girl whom I was attracted to nor did I end up dating anyone else who I was attracted to because they weren't Brahmins. At this point, all my friends have a girlfriend, who mostly aren't even of the same religion. I told my parents I am not interested in an arranged marriage because I cannot marry someone that I don't genuinely love and I cannot love someone without spending at least a year dating them and getting to know them. I asked them again if it was OK to date someone I like but my parents again gave the same answer from before.
At this point, I started losing faith in the community as a whole. I know my parents are good people and they love me. I also know that I am a good son, I never asked for any expensive stuff when I was young, I had decent grades, got a very good scholarship in the US for my undergrad, and have a high-paying job. I send money to them every month and cleared off all their loans.
But now I have a genuine question, does your kids' happiness mean so much less to you than to your pride in the community? Why is the Brahmin community as a whole quick to outcast someone because they didn't marry into the community (I genuinely believe this because I have witnessed this when I was a kid)? I am not questioning every individual who are Brahmin but trying to understand what goes on in some people's mind when they outcast someone in the 21st century for marrying because their kid married someone they loved? I don't really care if I am an outcast but my parents do.
At what point should I say enough is enough and decide that I will marry whom I love and not someone whom my parents believe is a good match. Because although I might be their kid, there is a lot in my life they don't know about. I am close to losing faith, throwing in the towel, and even consuming non-veg which I thought I never would because I genuinely don't understand all these restrictions in this modern age when people from other communities (not all) have so much freedom.
I am probably going to end up not marrying anyone in my life if my parents are opposed to me dating from outside the caste or religion. I was to open in my love life and marry who I want, if that's not possible I might as well end up a bachelor all my life. Let's see what option my parents choose.