..... I know you won't accept any of what I say......
Shankaracharya would not be laughed at if he were the leader of a political party(however small and inconsequential it may be) of dominant castes!!
Dear Raju,
My post was in response to the suggestion that we are, strike that, I was demanding Brahmins to collectively own up to some sort of past guilt and tender an apology to whom I know not. My intent was to disabuse such notions.
You have taken this discussion to a well trodden territory. That is fine, as you say I am unable to be persuaded by the citation of individual cases of defying the Brahminical order as in the case of Vaidyanatha Iyer (Aside: his grandson is a close friend of mine from my BHEL days) or the personal anecdotes of charity work of your family members. I can't accept your generalization of these instances.
Further, your characterization of what I am saying is wrong, I am not calling merely for some declarations from Acharyas. There must be genuine good will towards the oppressed. The fact is, the Dalit who gets oppressed by the Caste Hindus are saying these Thevars etc., are Brahmins in disguise. I want people to think about that. You may reject this as simply political, but that would not be wise. The reason Sankarachariyar, or any other Brahmnical acharyas, will be laughed at is not because they do not have political backing, it is because they represent Brahminism, one that is non different from Varna system for Dalits, thevars, naickers, and the other hundreds of jAtis.
I know there is visceral hatred for EVR. He was virulently anti-Brahmin, and many Brahmins, including you, are unable get past this. Rajaji, who is still a grand sire of politics, nationalism and religious faith for all Brahmins, could see past this anti-brahmin rhetoric of EVR and be a close friend of his, yet the Brahmins today are caught up in an emotional trap when it comes to EVR.
IMO, EVR is a Bharat Ratna. He instilled self-respect in all the oppressed people of Tamil Nadu, Dalit included. Whether EVR had Dalits in his close circle or not, the Dalits don't seem to care, they still hold him in very high esteem. EVR was one of only two public figures to call for complete emancipation of women, the other being Bhararthiyar. But EVR went farther than Bharathi. He was fearless in criticizing superstitions irrespective of source, he didn't pull his punches when it came to Tamil, he did not fall victim to language chauvinism like many of his chelas did. EVR is a shining light for many a forward thinking people interested in self-respect and social justice. A thousand years from now if one individual from Tamil Nadu will be remembered fondly it will be EVR.
Raju, you and I are destined not to see eye-to-eye on anything, except probably moderation -- brother KRS, just a joke!!!. But I am glad we can exchange views amicably. If Rajaji can be friends with EVR, I think you can be friends with me, no?
Cheers!
Every opinion based on scientific criticism I welcome. As to prejudices .. to which I have never made concessions ... “Segui il tuo corso, e lascia dir le genti.” -- Karl Marx