• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Religious conversion

  • Thread starter Thread starter CHANDRU1849
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Biswa and Ash,

Strategy guys! Strategy!

When facing with anyone whom you feel is your "opponent" never go into attack mode too soon.

Observe and then make a calculated move.

Hear out what your opponent has to say..sometimes the person might mean no harm so then you can be friends and see the logic behind what he/she says.

But if you feel there is no way you can see eye to eye...adopt a different strategy by having an exchange of opinions.

If that fails ..by the time the opinions have been exchanged we would have known some details and at times even the weakness of our opponent..only then launch an "attack" but make sure back up is there. A Lone Ranger seldom wins any battle..You need to have a Tonto to do your work in the background to keep you safe like how an Anti Virus performs background scan.

So Biswa and Ash..If I were a King I would never make you both my Generals..you both "launched attack" too fast and too soon!LOL

And if you were a queen?........
 
I will get an ELICHAVAYAN to be the King!

Interested? You may apply when I become a Queen!LOL

Dont forget to inform me when you become one. I will come there with a big grin all the way-big grin = ilichcha vaayi. I need time to train myself. Interested in training me before that next avatar of yours? LOL.
 
Dont forget to inform me when you become one. I will come there with a big grin all the way-big grin = ilichcha vaayi. I need time to train myself. Interested in training me before that next avatar of yours? LOL.

Sure why not.

Training is easy.

Just keep reciting Ba Ba Black Sheep Nursery Rhyme!

Reason : Cos all you need to know is to say 'Yes Sir Yes Sir 3 Bags Full"!LOL
 
Sure why not.

Training is easy.

Just keep reciting Ba Ba Black Sheep Nursery Rhyme!

Reason : Cos all you need to know is to say 'Yes Sir Yes Sir 3 Bags Full"!LOL

Now I understand how you became such a brilliant ilichcha vayini. LOL. Thanks for the tips.
 
Hey guys,

Admit it ..after Nara ji left forum..forum has been boring with no fights and all.

Now at least we have Kuvs..and see how everyone is getting charged and all geared up to fight.

So you see we all need fights to keep us going.

Assault ji where are you?? I thought you asked "what keeps you going"

Now you can see for yourself that Fights Keep Forum Going!LOL

Lets all mud wrestle! Yeah Baby Come on!

I am here ...bunked office and preparing for interviews :)..

You wanted a topic for fight ? let me think..Who is better ? Rajni or Kamal ( or Gabden Vijayakanth )

I am sure we ll have a lot of opinions on this..
 
You can find sikhs and sardarjis entering and praying in south temples; I have seen them virtually in any temple I visit. So what is your question. Even the constitution treats all sikhs, jains and budhdhist as part of hindus only.

I believe zail singh was not allowed inside golden temple. Need checking.

should the president of india be denied entry into a temple in the very country of which he is president, just because he is not a hindu? (recollect zail singh's case). does this not sound absurd?
 
I am here ...bunked office and preparing for interviews :)..

You wanted a topic for fight ? let me think..Who is better ? Rajni or Kamal ( or Gabden Vijayakanth )

I am sure we ll have a lot of opinions on this..

what topic yaar?? Its so old school.

Better topic is "Who is better? Sunny Leone or Priya Anjali Rai"LOL
 
Religious conversion.

Roberto_de_Nobili_(1577-1656),_gravure.webp Roberto de Nobili (1577- 1656)

While discussing the subject of Religious conversion, I wish to share information about Rev Fr. Roberto de Nobili who spent many years to propagate Christianity among the Tamils.

Roberto de Nobili was an Italian Jesuit born in Montepulciano, Tuscany, in September,1577. He was the first son of a nobleman, a general in the papal army. After his father's demise at the age of seventeen Roberto chose to join the Society of Jesus founded by Ignatious Loyola, in spite of opposition from his family,which had contributed numerous clerics to the Church , including several Cardinals and at two Popes.Thus in 1596, ignoring his family's wishes, he entered the Jesuit novitiate with the intention of becoming a foreign missionary. After a brilliant course of studies he sailed for the Indian mission in October, 1604, arriving at Goa on 20 May, 1605.

After a short stay at Cochin and among the fishermen in coramandal Coast, he moved in November, 1606, to Madurai, great cultural center of Tamils ruled by Telugu Nayaks, patrons of Vedic learning and Hinduism. Here he spent close to next fifty years in the service of his Lord.The policy of Portuguese clergy until then was to try and achieve to increase the number of converts, by conversion of the downtrodden lower classes to Christianity, sometimes forcefully, hardly making contacts with the upper castes. They set strict rules after conversions, getting the new recruits to eat meat, change their entire ways of life etc which earned them no good will, the converts were still considered lower class. The revised priority in India, therefore for the Jesuits, was to free Hindus from the stranglehold of the Brahmins as set by St Xavier. The resident Jesuit priest in Madurai was making not much headway with conversions and not a single Brahmin could be converted thus far. Instead the Portuguese and their Priests earned the sobriquet of Pirangis or Firangis, unclean white-men, bracketed with lower class people.

Soon, Fr.Roberto de Nobili understood the iron bound Caste system that held the Hindu society strongly. As a result, he decided to move ahead and accept the restrictions of caste and refuse to condemn any social custom or idea in this regard. First, he tried to ally the fear that he was a Portuguese (Pirangi) Priest, but a holy man from Italy like a Brahmin in India.. He moved from the missionary compound into a house in the Brahmin quarter of the city and shaved his head and sported a tuft of hair. He spoke only Tamil, hired a Brahmin cook and houseboy, and became a vegetarian. Like many Brahmins, Roberto de Nobili limited himself to one meal a day. He abandoned the black cassock and leather wear of the Jesuits for a saffron robe and wooden clogs. He put sandalwood paste on his forehead to like a Brahmin priest and even wore sacred thread across his shoulder for some time, as a sign of his caste rank.. He referred to himself as an ascetic or a sannyasi. Eventually, he preferred the company of Brahmins and even ate only with them. He bathed daily and cleansed himself ceremonially before saying mass. Thus it looked, instead of converting Brahmins, he converted himself as a Brahmin !

With the help of his scholarly Brahmin associate in the School run by Catholics, he learnt Sanskrit, Tamil and Telugu. In two years he mastered these languages to the extend of conversing fluently in Tamil and Telugu, and studying Sacred Texts of Vedas and Upanishads. Perhaps de Nobili was the " first European to study those venerable classics". In 1613 de Nobili wrote a detailed treatise on Hindu customs, and importance of careful adaptation of missionary methods, "Preaching Wisdom to the Wise- Three Treatises by Roberto de Nobili" which his Portuguese Jesuit superiors disagreed. However in 1623 Pope Gregory XV issued a papal document, that largely approved de Nobili's approach. Through the next forty-five years he wrote over twenty volumes of Catholic teachings in Sanskrit and Tamil.

Roberto de Nobili was a polyglot well versed in fourteen languages. "He composed Catechisms, apologetic works and philosophic discourses in Tamil, and contributed greatly to the development of modern Tamil prose writing". "As he expounded the Christian doctrine in Tamil he coined several words to communicate his message. He used the word "Kovil" (கோவில்) for a place of worship, "arul" (அருள்) and "prasadam" "(பிரசாதம்) for grace, "guru" (குரு) for priest or teacher, "Vedam" (வேதம்) for the Bible, "poosai" (பூசை) for Mass, etc".

Regarding number of Brahmin converts by de Nobili, there are different numbers given in books. But it was not significant. The reason as one author said, by getting converted, Brahmins viewed that they gain nothing. They enjoy status in society, looked after well by the rulers and the rich. Then why should they convert themselves to a new religion.

During his final years Roberto de Nobili courted many controversies and banished to Jaffna, where he had lost much of his eye sight. Eventually the Church refused to allow him back to his favorite Madurai, instead sent to San Thome, Mylapore, Madras, where after spending eight years as a broken, penniless and blind man Rev.Fr.Roberto de Nobili, the Count of Civitella died in the year 1656. His tomb is not identified till now.

Brahmanyan,
Bangalore.
 
Last edited:
Interesting account Mr. Brahmanyan. Is it fair to say then that de Nobili converted from being a Christian to being a Brahmin?
 
Here is a pix of Roberto de Nobili :) - poonal, chandanam, kaavi and a cross :)

RdeN.webp

another priest giuseppe beschi even changed his name to வீரமாமுனிவர் !! anything to buy the souls.

today, there is a movement among the paradhavars to go back to the mother religion. not vedic hinduism, which i think would be a disaster, but the world of ammans, sudalaimadans, ayyanars, madurai veerans and muniandis.

of non vedic and purely of tamil origin, these are closer to most of tamils (except tambrams i think) and an attempt to sanskritize them by importing brahmin priests and abolishing animal sacrifices has been, a gradual process, of gentrification.

murugan, a tamil god is already completely agama-ized. hopefully the tamil village deities maintain their exclusivity and authenticity, and retain their poosaris.

interestingly, when i was growing up, my mom used to visit mundagakanni amman kovil regularly, like all mylapore-ites. also in the midst of the slum settlement near my house, there used to be small amman kovilette.. and mom used to light lamp there regularly. through our servant maid.

faith. we have many gods and adding or subtracting a few, does not appear to make much difference. except when it comes heads on with xtianity or islam. oh well!!

... and then there is this christian brahmana seva samithi and their bhagavathar's kathaa kaalashepam. hilarious :)

CBSS.webp
 
Last edited:
Who imported brahmims for gentrification? A defunct theory of so called native tamilians. Brahmins were always part of the tamil population and are and were tamilians. No one can deny that all forms of worship coexisted. Brahmins never objected to the multiple practices including animal sacrifice; even the current brahmin chief minister who banned animal sacrifice in temples removed the ban within two years. Even now thousands of temples have nonbrahmin poosaris. They do follow their old traditions including bali.
 
interesting. in malaysia christ is referred as Allah in local text to appeal to locals. the christian priest there is being prosecuted by the govt for sedition
 
Who imported brahmims for gentrification? A defunct theory of so called native tamilians. Brahmins were always part of the tamil population and are and were tamilians. No one can deny that all forms of worship coexisted. Brahmins never objected to the multiple practices including animal sacrifice; even the current brahmin chief minister who banned animal sacrifice in temples removed the ban within two years. Even now thousands of temples have nonbrahmin poosaris. They do follow their old traditions including bali.

brahmins are not originally tamilians mr. sarang. all the brahmins were one, speaking sanskrit. brahmins spread, mingled with people of other linguistic groups. the descendants, as is norm, spoke the language of the mother and followed the faith system of the fathers. hence tamil brahmins, telugu brahmins, kannada brahmins, malayalam brahmins, marathi brahmins, bengali brahmins etc. that explains why brahmins caste is the only caste found in all language groups. you dont have a malayalam reddy, not telugu gounder or mudaliyar, nor kannada menon, nor tamil okkaliga, nor bengali gaekwar, nor marathi basu etc.

also explains why brahmins and only brahmins worship, chant and recite only sanskrit mantras.
 
"................of non vedic and purely of tamil origin, these are closer to most of tamils (except tambrams i think) and an attempt to sanskritize them by importing brahmin priests and abolishing animal sacrifices has been, a gradual process, of gentrification.

murugan, a tamil god is already completely agama-ized. hopefully the tamil village deities maintain their exclusivity and authenticity, and retain their poosaris.
.........."

thanks mr. kunjuppu. for a long time i was expecting some inputs in this regard. some more inputs please, regarding the indigenous, non-aryan-mixed, non-brahmin-mixed, non-sanskritized, pre-gentrification, pristine tamilian faith system that originated and existed in tamil nadu, of the tamilians, for the tamilians and by the tamilians, prior to being devoured by the non-tamilian faith systems.

perhaps we can start a separate thread for an elaborate discussion on the subject.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Latest ads

Back
Top