Interesting post Mr. K. So is Meenakshi amman Vedic or pagan?
dear biswa, i would desist the use of the term 'pagan'. it means different things for followers of different religion, and as i respect all religions, i feel, 'pagan' is a blasphemy. if you dont mind that is.
the cult of amman is uniquely tamil and kerala afaik. not sure about karnataka or andhra. in kerala we used to call them bhagavati and there are numerous bhagavati koils...the priests are NB and the functions like thali poli (for virgins) invariably end in animal sacrifice and komaram (god visiting the priest). pretty scary to watch.
same as our tamil ammans (each one has a story behind it, and many are memorials to some woman who died a tragic or brave death). again here the poosaris are NB and the prayers are what the poosaris make up in their own words. no scripted dialogue with God. goat or chicken sacrificed.
i think vedic hinduism came with the cholas for sure as cholas distinctively treated the brahmins reverently, granted them land and largesse, at the expense of villagers, who were arbitrarily taxed for the sake of the brahmins, and that too for perpetuity. probably this started the anti brahmin feelings among tamils, as there are kalvettu records of agitations against largesses to brahmins from lands expropirated by the king. unfortunately i cannot cite the sources now.. but these are authentic among kalvettus (stone inscriptions) and copper plates.
my aunt who went to velanganni, felt the presence of amman, in the lady of velankanni. there is a velankanni church in besant nagar, and in late august they have an annual festival for which pilgrims come walking from long distances. all wear the distinct kaavi of hindu heritage.
the quest towards the next world's comfort and happiness, to me, appears to be paramount, to those deprived of material comforts of this world, and who dream of it in the next. the exception may be the residents of the gulf countries, who still appear to adhere to a extreme form of islam even though these have money coming through their ears for the past 40+ years. and ofcourse saudi, where jihadists appear to mushroom inspite of all the oil wealth. why? i dont know.