N
Nara
Guest
Dear Ravi and Kasi,
I am unable to quite understand what you are arguing for. Are you saying that Brahmins must help each other out, and that is it? If this is so, then you are expecting narrow caste feelings to produce some miraculously beneficial outcomes. Is this not an unreasonable expectation? How can you expect a truly altruistic outcome from a selfish premise such as "my caste"? May be the Chettiyars and Nadars have managed it, but who knows what the inside story is.
I think we need to think of humanity as our "community", not just Brahmins. You two, and RR, have experienced unsympathetic responses from fellow Brahmins, and, I am with you all the way on that count. In the case of Kasi, the positive response came from a sympathetic NB lady. Does this not tell us that caste has no significance when it comes to true human values? Does this not tell you that there is nothing compassionate about narrowing our compassion only to Brahmins? Let us think more broadly. The lowly thotti is as much a part of our community as the exalted observant poor Brahmin.
Kasi and Ravi, from what I have observed, you two are very considerate human beings. Your friends are fortunate to have you as their friends. I request you to let go of narrow and restrictive considerations such as caste. Let us broaden our scope. An abject poor Brahmin can always find at least two two square meals a day in a Brahminical Matam. But abjectly poor Dalit or lower caste Shudra, still have to struggle -- what indignities they have to suffer, I shudder to even speculate.
regards ...
I am unable to quite understand what you are arguing for. Are you saying that Brahmins must help each other out, and that is it? If this is so, then you are expecting narrow caste feelings to produce some miraculously beneficial outcomes. Is this not an unreasonable expectation? How can you expect a truly altruistic outcome from a selfish premise such as "my caste"? May be the Chettiyars and Nadars have managed it, but who knows what the inside story is.
I think we need to think of humanity as our "community", not just Brahmins. You two, and RR, have experienced unsympathetic responses from fellow Brahmins, and, I am with you all the way on that count. In the case of Kasi, the positive response came from a sympathetic NB lady. Does this not tell us that caste has no significance when it comes to true human values? Does this not tell you that there is nothing compassionate about narrowing our compassion only to Brahmins? Let us think more broadly. The lowly thotti is as much a part of our community as the exalted observant poor Brahmin.
Kasi and Ravi, from what I have observed, you two are very considerate human beings. Your friends are fortunate to have you as their friends. I request you to let go of narrow and restrictive considerations such as caste. Let us broaden our scope. An abject poor Brahmin can always find at least two two square meals a day in a Brahminical Matam. But abjectly poor Dalit or lower caste Shudra, still have to struggle -- what indignities they have to suffer, I shudder to even speculate.
regards ...